Title: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Nem on July 10, 2006, 11:00:31 PM Zidane's factfile (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zidane)
Maradona's factfile (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maradona) Pele's factfile (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pele) Johan Cruyff's factfile (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cruyff) [attachment deleted by admin] Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballerof all time? Post by: The Baron on July 10, 2006, 11:04:04 PM Quite simply, Pele.
The greatest player to ever grace the game. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballerof all time? Post by: ifm on July 10, 2006, 11:06:01 PM Only 4 options?
Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballerof all time? Post by: Nem on July 10, 2006, 11:06:39 PM Quite simply, Pele. The greatest player to ever grace the game. Not as good as either Zidane or Maradona IMO. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballerof all time? Post by: Nem on July 10, 2006, 11:07:29 PM Only 4 options? Yes. They are the best players of their generations from the last 40 years. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: B/FsCousinKev on July 10, 2006, 11:12:10 PM Ive gone for the one who was fat,one- footed and rubbish in the air "MARADONA" rotflmfao
Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: ifm on July 10, 2006, 11:13:05 PM Charlton, Platini, Beckenbauer, Garrincha, Muller, van Basten, best, Eusebio, Rossi, Puskas, Di Stefano???
Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Nem on July 10, 2006, 11:14:58 PM Charlton, Platini, Beckenbauer, Garrincha, Muller, van Basten, best, Eusebio, Rossi, Puskas, Di Stefano??? All great players, but not as good as the top 4. Puskas and Di Stefano were from the early 50's Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: booder on July 10, 2006, 11:16:09 PM Ive gone for the one who was fat,one- footed and rubbish in the air colchester kev ? Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Nem on July 10, 2006, 11:17:30 PM Ive gone for the one who was fat,one- footed and rubbish in the air "MARADONA" rotflmfao Check out his factfile! Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballerof all time? Post by: The Baron on July 10, 2006, 11:20:26 PM Quite simply, Pele. The greatest player to ever grace the game. Not as good as either Zidane or Maradona IMO. I rate Zidane and Maradona very highly but Pele was something else. Two footed, balance, pace, acceleration, bravery, heading, (5"8!) he also looked after himself (unlike Maradona) and had a longer and more successful international career. To be honest for similar reasons I rate Zidane almost as highly. Maradona had the best left foot ever but no right foot at all. Also for a player to stand out so badly from that 1970 team is bordering on the ridiculous. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: B/FsCousinKev on July 10, 2006, 11:21:57 PM Ive gone for the one who was fat,one- footed and rubbish in the air "MARADONA" rotflmfao Check out his factfile! Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballerof all time? Post by: Nem on July 10, 2006, 11:27:45 PM Quite simply, Pele. The greatest player to ever grace the game. Not as good as either Zidane or Maradona IMO. I rate Zidane and Maradona very highly but Pele was something else. Two footed, balance, pace, acceleration, bravery, heading, (5"8!) he also looked after himself (unlike Maradona) and had a longer and more successful international career. To be honest for similar reasons I rate Zidane almost as highly. Maradona had the best left foot ever but no right foot at all. Also for a player to stand out so badly from that 1970 team is bordering on the ridiculous. Yes, but football has improved greatly in 40 years! Pele was a great player, among relatively modest players. He only played in Brazil and never played aborad in the top european leagues. Zidane and Maradona were kings among great players. Cruyff played at the top for 20 years! Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: ACE2M on July 11, 2006, 11:16:42 AM Zidane and Maradona were kings among great players. Cruyff played at the top for 20 years! and he was on 20 a day!!! maradona was the best player ever, no doubt about it. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Rod Paradise on July 11, 2006, 11:17:23 AM There's no way you can say Puskas and DiStephano were from the 1950's, discount them & then call the poll the best player ever >:?.
Especially as their most famous game together was in the 60's when they scored 7 goals between them in a European Cup final. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballerof all time? Post by: The Baron on July 11, 2006, 02:09:48 PM Quite simply, Pele. The greatest player to ever grace the game. Not as good as either Zidane or Maradona IMO. I rate Zidane and Maradona very highly but Pele was something else. Two footed, balance, pace, acceleration, bravery, heading, (5"8!) he also looked after himself (unlike Maradona) and had a longer and more successful international career. To be honest for similar reasons I rate Zidane almost as highly. Maradona had the best left foot ever but no right foot at all. Also for a player to stand out so badly from that 1970 team is bordering on the ridiculous. Yes, but football has improved greatly in 40 years! Pele was a great player, among relatively modest players. He only played in Brazil and never played aborad in the top european leagues. Zidane and Maradona were kings among great players. Cruyff played at the top for 20 years! Pele didn't play a board as his government declared him a national treasure and wouldn't let him leave! This did not happen to Maradona or anyone since. Back then the elite in football met in the World Cup not the Champions League like today so to say Pele didn't do it on the big stage is ludicrous. 3 world cups out of 4 says it all. The one he didn't win was because he was kicked about by the Portugese (who seem to cheat in any era) and had to hop through a game on one leg in a time with no substitutes. Maradona had a shorter career than Pele, he played in much better club teams that were bought with huge budgets. Even then those teams did not compare to the other great team of that era, thee Milan side. So Maradona's club exploits dont impress me that much to be honest. Thinking about his footballing ability I would even put Maradona behind Zidane. Zidane is more complete than Maradona in terms of using both feet, shooting, heading and interlinking play. He is on a par with Pele but Pele did it first in a time where World Cups were, if anything, more competitive with many countries with many great players. Look at your World XI for this World Cup. You think they'd have had trouble finding strikers for that list in Pele's time? Pele = GOAT. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: marcro on July 11, 2006, 02:17:51 PM I am surprised that there is a debate on this - Pele is the best footballer the world has seen.
Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: thetank on July 11, 2006, 02:26:11 PM I agree with Rod.
The poll's name is "Greatest footballer of all time" then the question asks from 1960's onwards. How the fock is 1960-Present Day "all-time" :dontask: I'm voting Pele coz he was a lovely bloke, and that gets you points in my bizarre little world. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Newportlad on July 11, 2006, 05:44:47 PM I dont see Dalglish on that list...
Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Nem on July 11, 2006, 05:47:56 PM I dont see Dalglish on that list... rotflmfao or Jinky Johnson - A player for whom some Celtic fans think is the greatest player to ever play football. >:? Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Triple X on July 11, 2006, 09:41:03 PM Truth is there are no right answers - they were all the best of their generation.
I must say though that having gone to Sunday's final I have never watched a player like Zidane - it was an honour to be in the same stadium as him (up to the 107th minute!!). His skill, strength, vision, influence are way beyond any other player that i have ever watched live. I watch Thierry Henry week in week out and believed not only was he world class but also out of this world and obviously everyone raves about Ronaldinho but Zidane for me is streets ahead of the current generation. And this was his swansong. We almost forget how good he was in 1998 and 2000! Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Rod Paradise on July 12, 2006, 09:36:08 AM I dont see Dalglish on that list... rotflmfao or Jinky Johnson - A player for whom some Celtic fans think is the greatest player to ever play football. >:? Funny enough Di Sptephano was a huge fan of the wee man. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Nem on July 12, 2006, 04:48:41 PM Jinky Johnson - A player for whom some Celtic fans think is the greatest player to ever play football. >:? Funny enough Di Sptephano was a huge fan of the wee man. rotflmfao Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Rod Paradise on July 13, 2006, 10:40:56 AM Nem, a lack of knowledge is not covered up by a rotflmfao . ;tk;
I'll bring you a copy of 'The Lord of The Wing' video to BB3. Watch it and listen do Di Stefano talk about the wee man. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: mikkyT on July 13, 2006, 11:51:43 AM Lord of the wing he was...
Greatest footballer of all time he wasn't. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Rod Paradise on July 13, 2006, 12:02:15 PM Lord of the wing he was... Greatest footballer of all time he wasn't. Funny enough that's not what I'm saying. Just replying to Nem's pop at him. I'd have Di Stefano or Pele. I doubt that either of them would have minded having the wee man in their team though. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: happybhoy on July 13, 2006, 12:09:26 PM I think the poll is broken the link for Henrik Larsson doesn't show up.
:dontask: Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: boldie on July 13, 2006, 12:18:19 PM you always have a problem with this sort of thing. Pele was the greatest of his generation..9only the brazilians themselves disagree and name Garrincha as the greatest.) Garrincha was the last amatuer and Pele the first pro...I think that sums him up.
then came Cruyff...unrivalled in the 70's...after that Maradonna...noone better in the 80's (van basten could never prove ow good he realoly was as the bastards broke him)....and then Zidane in the 90's....the 2000's will belong to Henry or Ronaldhino. Overall...I'd have to go with Pele though... Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: raab11 on July 13, 2006, 09:29:35 PM it has to be diego armando if only for the greatest goal ever, against england in 86 his second goal was ok too....... Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: A$$A$$IN on July 14, 2006, 04:34:36 PM Maradona, Maradona, Maradona.
Pele was a great player in great teams who could have won without him. Maradona was a great player in very ordinary teams i.e. Argentina and Naples who would have won nothing without him. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: The Baron on July 14, 2006, 05:04:33 PM Maradona, Maradona, Maradona. Pele was a great player in great teams who could have won without him. Maradona was a great player in very ordinary teams i.e. Argentina and Naples who would have won nothing without him. I was kind of waiting for this, but Napoli werent average one bit. They did a Blackburn and went and spent an arm and a leg to buy the title. Also I don't believe Argentina were average in 86 or 90 one bit. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Nem on July 14, 2006, 05:30:18 PM Also I don't believe Argentina were average in 86 or 90 one bit. They wasn't the best team in either World Cup without him. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: The_Patriot on July 15, 2006, 12:56:19 AM nemesis and everyone else, if its a question of talent and in that I mean the greatest footballer ever to grace a football park, then its simply George Best.
Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Nem on July 15, 2006, 08:36:49 AM nemesis and everyone else, if its a question of talent and in that I mean the greatest footballer ever to grace a football park, then its simply George Best. No way. Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Colchester Kev on July 15, 2006, 11:08:36 AM nemesis and everyone else, if its a question of talent and in that I mean the greatest footballer ever to grace a football park, then its simply George Best. Most gifted/talented player ... George best by a million miles. Best Player in terms of career ... Pele debate over ;) Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Lee on July 15, 2006, 11:14:15 AM Emile Heskey must be close surely?
Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: Colchester Kev on July 15, 2006, 11:22:31 AM Emile Heskey must be close surely? Yes Heskey is currently top of the poll ..... for players that couldnt hit a cows arse with a banjo :D :D :D Title: Re: POLL: Who is The Greatest Footballer of all time? Post by: leighton_87 on July 15, 2006, 02:23:07 PM Yes Heskey is currently top of the poll ..... for players that couldnt hit a cows arse with a banjo :D :D :D I think he's second behind the England penalty takers |