Title: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: kvnstv on September 28, 2006, 11:38:42 AM Ericstoners post about William hill effectively cutting itself of from US clients has made me re examine my previously held belief that the legal proceedings being championed by some US senators (financially backed by some very interested parties*) with the full support of the current US administration’s efforts to prevent there own citizens making a reasoned choice to use there own funds how they choose was something akin to King Canute trying to hold back the tide.
I know that from inception some European owned poker sites like Ladbrokes have prevented US based customers from opening accounts but for a major poker/sportsbook to actually begin to turn away customers is a very interesting development. Surely there can’t be too many reasons for a bookie to turn away business; It’s not worth it? Unlikely US pretty big place! It’s illegal? Well arguable point at the moment. It’s soon going to be illegal? If the current bill’s in front of the US senate do pass how enforceable will they be, although I’m an IT manager I know very little about what sort of preventive measures are available but I did speak to our network manager who said that as long as full cooperation is available with ISP’s then its quite straight forward to put blocks in place. Of course people will find ways around this so what are they going to do start locking up recreational poker players, two years for a 10$ S+G seems a bit harsh! What’s the likely affect on such a massive reduction in online players? Could the potential opening of the Asian markets offset the US loss? * The sponsor Senator for the Washington state law was one, Margarita Prentice (D) 11th District, and here are some of her financial supporters - WA INDIAN GAMING ASSN OLYMPIA WA NISQUALLY INDIAN TRIBE OLYMPIA WA MUCKLESHOOT INDIAN TRIBE AUBURN WA CHIPS CASINO LLC BREMERTON WA CONF TRIBES OF COLVILLE RESERVATION NESPELEM WA GOLDIE'S SHORELINE CASINO SHORELINE WA So no conflict on interest there then! Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: boldie on September 28, 2006, 01:08:44 PM I said it when the news first came out, this will have a massive impact on the online poker scene.
People forget that they left out betting on Horse racing in this bill. The banning of gambling on horseracing online is the only thing that has stopped this bill in the past and now that that is out there is a very good chance of the bill actually going ahead. conflicts of interest is not something that ussually stops a Senator from acting on something..in fact lobbyists are very well paid for a reason. Those guys aren't charity workers, they represent a billion dollar industry and can essentially get someone elected, that's what matters. If the lobbyists for casino's are told to push something, they will. They have the money and therefore they have the power to do so. Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: Acidmouse on September 28, 2006, 01:14:01 PM If the gun and anti abortion lobby's can have so much power I am sure the same can be done for the "tinternet gambling lobby" could.
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: boldie on September 28, 2006, 01:15:10 PM If the gun and anti abortion lobby's can have so much power I am sure the same can be done for the "tinternet gambling lobby" could. yes but you forget..tinternet gambling lobby is not as powerfull as the casino lobby as the casino's pay taxes in the states. Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: Acidmouse on September 28, 2006, 01:18:13 PM Will it effect us much if no American's can play Online? just interested, wife was asking me (she's a yank)
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: SupaMonkey on September 28, 2006, 01:19:56 PM Will it effect us much if no American's can play Online? just interested, wife was asking me (she's a yank) Yes, the games will become much harder. rotflmfao Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: Acidmouse on September 28, 2006, 01:24:18 PM I got banned a few months back from a rather large USA poker forum for daring to find it funny that they are trying to ban online poker there. People accusing me of being Anti-American and such, always makes me chuckle.
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: boldie on September 28, 2006, 01:30:25 PM I got banned a few months back from a rather large USA poker forum for daring to find it funny that they are trying to ban online poker there. People accusing me of being Anti-American and such, always makes me chuckle. hahaha..they are a funny bunch. I have a very good friend who's American and he cracks me up sometimes with his opinions and lack of knowledge..and general sensitivity about being a yank...while proclaimiing to be proud of it....that's the thing that really cracks me up. (I still love him like a brother though...actually he is a "bruvva" but that's not what I meant) I am proud to be american!....but I will go on tilt if I think you critisize me as I'm soo insecure lol Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: kvnstv on September 28, 2006, 01:42:33 PM Above all I just find the whole thing weird, you can drive down the road to gamble in a reservation casino but cant do it from the comfort of your own home. You can back horse's online with the racetrack sites and buy lottery tickets but cant play poker or bet on sports? Theres no rhyme or reason to it, but then again they are American so shouldnt expect any.
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: Royal Flush on September 28, 2006, 05:00:12 PM Will it effect us much if no American's can play Online? just interested, wife was asking me (she's a yank) Yes, the games will become much harder. rotflmfao Try the complete opposite! Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: totalise on September 30, 2006, 03:05:03 AM this is lookin real bad.. apparently an Internet Gambling Language was attached to some stupid Port defence bill and will go before the senate tonight, if it gets through (which it looks certain it will) its pretty much curtains for online gaming in the US, depending on the language of the bill.
Speculation is rife, some say it will only affect banks/credit cards.. so neteller will be ok, and some speculate that the ISP's will be banning them from signing into pokesites, and that banks will refuse to have anything to do with neteller. Flushy says the games will get easier, but I disagree entirely... where is the money gonna come from? even if the players are allowed to log into pokersites, its gonna get real hard to get money into them, and the average fish in america wont want to jump through the hoops to deposit, so its just gonna leave the better players playing. The games are gonna get very tough. If they do ban it completely, then it will restrict a huge inflow of money trickling in. Its like a pyramid, money flows in, $100 at a time, and it trickles upwards through the stakes. Without this money coming into the economy, it can dry out very quickly. Its a grave situation for sure.... and the ban is going to be terrible for the game, not in any way good. Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: Sark79 on September 30, 2006, 10:28:43 AM Aren't the US players generally better than anywhere else? judging by alot of online lists such as the mtt leader-board on P5's almost all the top spots are filled with players from North America
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: byronkincaid on September 30, 2006, 10:40:24 AM That's the point sark, the good yanks will find a way to play and the millions of yank fish will think it's too much hassle and do something else.
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: byronkincaid on September 30, 2006, 11:01:57 AM I guess there's a way to make some money out of this by shorting Party, 888 etc? Would spread betting be the easiest way?
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: Sark79 on September 30, 2006, 11:02:04 AM But this group of good US players will be outnumbered ( if that's a word? :D ) by Europeans, parts of Asia, etc. Surely with a larger player base from elsewhere, a nationality other than one of the top Americans will win.
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: crip17 on September 30, 2006, 11:09:41 AM The bill has just been passed. Now over to president Bush to sign. Where's Jack Bauer when u really need him HUH
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: Sark79 on September 30, 2006, 11:10:51 AM PM Flushy, he knows Jack Bauer well. They learned to fly planes at the same flight school
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: boldie on September 30, 2006, 06:46:22 PM The bill has just been passed. Now over to president Bush to sign. Where's Jack Bauer when u really need him HUH yep....trouble ahead. I expect to see some websites moving their servers to the states now to allow US players to play...but it spells trouble for online poker. Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: snoopy1239 on September 30, 2006, 06:48:54 PM http://www.blondepoker.com/index.php?q=node/4332 (http://www.blondepoker.com/index.php?q=node/4332) Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: snoopy1239 on September 30, 2006, 07:00:29 PM On a personal basis, this a big concern for me as an online player.
I depend almost entirely on the American market, so to have this bill passed and only a Presidential signature away from being confirmed is a huge catastrophe. I just hope that opposition is so huge and intense that the bill is, if not overturned, at least delayed. Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: glenner on September 30, 2006, 07:56:14 PM moet een juiste baan nu worden
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: boldie on September 30, 2006, 08:03:00 PM moet een juiste baan nu worden translation for no dutch speakers. "has to be a proper job now" Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: MrMoves on September 30, 2006, 09:10:44 PM Guys, please remember there are successful online poker rooms (Ladbrokes) that have never accepted US players.
This is not the end. Online poker is here to stay. Don't panic, Mr Mainwaring. Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: Longy on September 30, 2006, 10:27:10 PM I agree with Mr Moves that our ability to play poker is not in any danger, there may well be downsizing in the industry and some sites may well go under as the market shrinks but there will still be sites out there to play on.
My main concern is the traffic of players, this legislation is going to stop new and bad american players depositing and they will no longer be there. We maybe left with the more motivated ones who will find loopholes, the problem with these players is if they are motivated to do this, they will be motivated to be good poker players. As a multi tabling relative small stakes online pro my main donators will no longer be there is such numbers, for example according to stats i recently saw Party has an 80% turnover of players in a 6 month period, now that is scary given well over half of them are american. We are taliking around 40% of partys traffic disappearing very quickly. There are strong rumours that the legislation will be very wide stopping such sites as neteller and firepay being deposited into from american bank account. Or even blocking deposit by monitioring ip addresses. I know that stars already use this security feature as i was stopped from depositing when i recently went on holiday due to my ip address being in Egypt. I also have to say the USA has always been a place that has bemused me politcally and morally. This is another fine example of the land of the free being anything but that. Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: AndrewT on September 30, 2006, 10:40:32 PM 'Why do they hate us? ... They hate our freedoms' - George W Bush
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I k Post by: TightEnd on September 30, 2006, 11:03:21 PM I just hope that opposition is so huge and intense that the bill is, if not overturned, at least delayed. there isn't much coherent opposition and what little corporate opposition there is offshore and not US taxpayers, the vested interests in pushing the bill thourgh (financial institutions, the moral republican right wing, the land based casino interests, the money laundering authorities) are huge Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: kvnstv on October 01, 2006, 01:51:03 PM As I understand it the American government now has 270 days to introduce measures to prevent movement from US based financial organisations to poker sites and e-wallets. Is this likely to cause a bit of a run of withdrawals on some sites? Is my 30 quid on party safe!!!!
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: MrMoves on October 01, 2006, 02:05:20 PM Your 30 quid is safe unless it's 30 quids worth of shares. In which case it'll be worth about 10 quid at 9am tomorrow.
Title: Re: Is it going to happen? No more American poker players online? Old debate I know. Post by: kvnstv on October 01, 2006, 02:10:34 PM Cheers Paul, I was going to use that 30 quid to buy shoes for the nipper. phew!!!
|