|
Title: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 01:12:20 PM Having huge argument with a friend about who the best 3 players are in each position in the premiership. Anyone wanna take a stab?
GK RB LB CB RW LW DM AM No 9 No 10 Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 19, 2011, 01:49:07 PM Its tough to say RW, LW, and AM, as they all play so varied roles. Like, where would you put Nasri? Can play RW, LW or AM. Will have a go though
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 02:01:25 PM Its tough to say RW, LW, and AM, as they all play so varied roles. Like, where would you put Nasri? Can play RW, LW or AM. Will have a go though Attacking midfield mate. Some of my mates are horrendous. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 19, 2011, 02:06:08 PM Just done these in about 5 mins, so berate away. Probs missed 1 or 2. What you think?
GK. Cech, Reina, Hart RB Sagna, Ivanovic, Rafael (i guess, not a lot to pick from) LB Cole, Baines, Evra CB Vidic, Terry, Ferdinand RW Walcott, Nani, Young LW Bale, Silva, Malouda DM Essien, De Jong, Song AM Fabregas, Nasri, Gerrard No 9 Tevez, Drogba, Torres No 10 Van Persie, Rooney, Ricardo Fuller What are yours Pleno? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Josedinho on January 19, 2011, 02:06:41 PM GK - Reina, Begovic, VDS
RB - Sagna, Ivanovic, Hutton LB - Cole, Enrique, Evra CB - Vidic, Ferdinand, Vermaelen (sp) RW - Nani, Johnson, Young LW - Bale, Malouda, Etherington DM - De Jong, Essien, Fletcher AM - Modric, Silva, Nasri No 9 - Drogba, Tevez, Torres No 10 - Van Persie, Van Der Vaart, Rooney Based on this season. Off the top of my head. Assuming 1 position per player so cannot repeat Silva, Nasri etc. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 19, 2011, 02:14:34 PM Will do it in a bit. If anyone puts Giggs LW they are a joker. (assuming its on current ability)
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 19, 2011, 02:15:11 PM haha Rich has included The Black Panther as number 10!
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 02:16:40 PM Will do it in a bit. If anyone puts Giggs LW they are a joker. (assuming its on current ability) On the same terms surely your mates pick of Gerrard is equally a joke? Also, Lennon >>Young IMO Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 19, 2011, 02:18:17 PM haha, its started already. Gerrard is a brilliant footballer, will have to play the injuries card on that one again as hes been out for a couple of months and only just getting back in the swing of things.
Lennon is better than Young i agree. Oh, and hes not my mate, i fucking despise him. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 02:20:12 PM Oh and Rooney, lul
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 19, 2011, 02:28:05 PM Oh and Rooney, lul lol, as if you cant include him. You didnt say current ability, just best players in Prem. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 02:29:51 PM Then why havn't you got Shearer in? He's scored as many goals as Rooney this season..
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 19, 2011, 02:38:28 PM Doing a prop with a mate where we pick top 20 players of all time and then ask frineds and whoever gets most +1's wins the prop. He is talking about having Cannavaro and Bergkamp as certs and how its so standard. Has to be in order too btw. Just going to put mine down quickly as got uni at 9 but will update it over next few days, suggestions too pls. 1.Pele 2.Maradona 3.Zidane 4.Johan Cruyff 5.Messi 6.Platini 7.George Best 8.Puskas 9.Eusebio 10.Gullit 11.Fat Ronaldo 12.? 13.Beckenbauwer 14.Shearer 15.Hagi 16.Ronaldo 17.Rooney 18.Maldini 19.Figo 20.Oliver Kahn Pretty sure it was you that included Rooney in your all time top 20 footballers, LULLLLLLLLLLS Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 02:40:29 PM wp.
I guess that shows us that putting younger players into all time great lists is just absolutely ridiculous. I think I was swayed heavily by Mondatoo propaganda though, in my defence. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 19, 2011, 02:47:08 PM yeah, only 2 players id say in top 20 of all time that i can think of currently is Messi and Ronaldo. Still really young, both absolutely fantastic and always on form.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: boldie on January 19, 2011, 02:51:22 PM yeah, only 2 players id say in top 20 of all time that i can think of currently is Messi and Ronaldo. Still really young, both absolutely fantastic and always on form. Add Xavi and Iniesta to that for me. In fact, screw this best team and players of all time list and just say Barca Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 19, 2011, 02:58:33 PM I just see Number 9 as the main striker, aka Torres, Tevez, Drogba. Then number 10, a player who drops a bit deeper and isnt an out and out striker, aka a Rooney or a Van Perise. hmmm and? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 19, 2011, 03:00:12 PM I just see Number 9 as the main striker, aka Torres, Tevez, Drogba. Then number 10, a player who drops a bit deeper and isnt an out and out striker, aka a Rooney or a Van Perise. hmmm and? you asked the question bud, just too ashamed to keep your terrible post up. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 19, 2011, 03:01:54 PM ;joestrummer;
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 19, 2011, 03:02:03 PM yeah, only 2 players id say in top 20 of all time that i can think of currently is Messi and Ronaldo. Still really young, both absolutely fantastic and always on form. Add Xavi and Iniesta to that for me. In fact, screw this best team and players of all time list and just say Barca true they are brilliant. They could possibly make list somewhere. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 19, 2011, 03:08:52 PM cba doing another post because Rich and Josedinho's i agree largely with.
I definetly think Kolo Toure is better than Ferdinand (Kolo was voted best in the prem a few months back) and would have Micah Richards as RB #3. Maybe Dzeko at 10 if you can without him being proven in the prem. Seen loads of amazing finishes from him on you tube. Title: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 03:17:29 PM cba doing another post because Rich and Josedinho's i agree largely with. I definetly think Kolo Toure is better than Ferdinand (Kolo was voted best in the prem a few months back) and would have Micah Richards as RB #3. Maybe Dzeko at 10 if you can without him being proven in the prem. Seen loads of amazing finishes from him on you tube. come on, it's not going to work. I won't let you suck me in like this Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: toddswain on January 19, 2011, 05:57:26 PM +1 to no Rio,Rooney comments.
Ill do one later because tbh, i just cba right now Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 19, 2011, 07:17:22 PM Based on form and my honest opinion.
GK - Hart, Reina, Cech RB - Coleman, Hutton, Habib Beye LB - Enrique, Evra, Cole CB - Vidic, Collocini, Jagielka RW - Lennon, Jarvis, Nani LW - Ben Arfa, Malouda, Bale DM - Tiote, Essien, Barton AM - Nasri, Fabregas, Mereiles No 9 - Van Persie, Berbatov, Drogba No 10 - Tevez, Gyan, Van Der Vaart Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: toddswain on January 19, 2011, 08:56:08 PM How have you slipped Barton into DM, he sure plays there
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 19, 2011, 10:54:56 PM /thread
Was clearly just a plan all along from Pleno to try and make people react and argue when he puts the entire Newcastle X1 and Raul Mereiles (possibly the worst AM in the country this season) in there. Get a life pal. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: The Camel on January 19, 2011, 11:07:53 PM cba doing another post because Rich and Josedinho's i agree largely with. I definetly think Kolo Toure is better than Ferdinand (Kolo was voted best in the prem a few months back) and would have Micah Richards as RB #3. Maybe Dzeko at 10 if you can without him being proven in the prem. Seen loads of amazing finishes from him on you tube. Micah Richards is tez. No way he's top 3 rb, he's better at cb but only just about top 15 in that position. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Acidmouse on January 19, 2011, 11:15:01 PM Based on form and my honest opinion. GK - Hart, Reina, Cech RB - Coleman, Hutton, Habib Beye LB - Enrique, Evra, Cole CB - Vidic, Collocini, Jagielka RW - Lennon, Jarvis, Nani LW - Ben Arfa, Malouda, Bale DM - Tiote, Essien, Barton AM - Nasri, Fabregas, Mereiles No 9 - Van Persie, Berbatov, Drogba No 10 - Tevez, Gyan, Van Der Vaart erm. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 12:30:45 AM /thread Was clearly just a plan all along from Pleno to try and make people react and argue when he puts the entire Newcastle X1 and Raul Mereiles (possibly the worst AM in the country this season) in there. Get a life pal. Which Newcastle players do you disagree with bud? The only questionable one is Joey Barton and I think he has been absolutely superb this season, without a doubt top 10 midfielders if not top 5. If I was trying to get as many Newcastle players in the team then I would obv have put Carroll in but I put Gyan from down the road in instead. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 20, 2011, 01:01:34 AM Trust me Nolan is awful. He did well at start of season scoring goals, but now clubs are aware of hi they mark him and he doesnt offer anything. If he plays for us in Premiership, we will 100% go down he is tez. Carroll 11 Nolan 10 Ameobi 4 Barton 2 Best 3 Lovenkrands 2 9 Newcastle 22 3 29 Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: The Camel on January 20, 2011, 01:05:26 AM /thread Was clearly just a plan all along from Pleno to try and make people react and argue when he puts the entire Newcastle X1 and Raul Mereiles (possibly the worst AM in the country this season) in there. Get a life pal. Which Newcastle players do you disagree with bud? The only questionable one is Joey Barton and I think he has been absolutely superb this season, without a doubt top 10 midfielders if not top 5. If I was trying to get as many Newcastle players in the team then I would obv have put Carroll in but I put Gyan from down the road in instead. Having Collocini in your top 3 cb's proves without doubt it a comedy selection. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 20, 2011, 01:05:40 AM You gotta be less biased imo!
Gotta disagree with your Ben Arfa shout, uve seen him play 4 games for you until he got injured. Theres no way you could possibly think he was the best LW in the prem from just 4 performances. Your Collocini shouts pretty com. And you cant possibly lol at my Gerrard AM shout, then include Raul 'no show for half a season' Meireles in your best 3 AM's. Got to be a level, although i really dont think your joking. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: George2Loose on January 20, 2011, 01:08:46 AM lol wp pleno. WP
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 01:26:23 AM Collocini is pure class. There are so many "decent" centre halfs, trust me he is pure quality. Didn't say Ben Arfa was the best, but think he is in top 3. Looking through each position its clear the premiership isn't THAT GREAT. I stand by my pics though.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: George2Loose on January 20, 2011, 02:11:59 AM whole thread is a massive level
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: NoflopsHomer on January 20, 2011, 03:33:14 AM Norrr, Brent, where has your photoshop gone? :(
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Acidmouse on January 20, 2011, 10:23:08 AM Collocini is pure class. There are so many "decent" centre halfs, trust me he is pure quality. Didn't say Ben Arfa was the best, but think he is in top 3. Looking through each position its clear the premiership isn't THAT GREAT. I stand by my pics though. I have always been against your Nolan stance, I dont for one min think he is a world class player, but for Newscastle he will score the goals that might make the difference come end of the season. But when someone tells me Collocini is class this really makes me question if you can see past the black and white blinkers? I mean I have seen him numerous times and each one hes looked like he is totally out of his depth and struggling. You put him next to a fit Woodgate and then you will realise what class actually is. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 20, 2011, 10:34:31 AM Norrr, Brent, where has your photoshop gone? :( Got some info which made it invalid so deleted it. Did you get on Berankis in the tennis? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 10:38:12 AM Collocini is pure class. There are so many "decent" centre halfs, trust me he is pure quality. Didn't say Ben Arfa was the best, but think he is in top 3. Looking through each position its clear the premiership isn't THAT GREAT. I stand by my pics though. I have always been against your Nolan stance, I dont for one min think he is a world class player, but for Newscastle he will score the goals that might make the difference come end of the season. But when someone tells me Collocini is class this really makes me question if you can see past the black and white blinkers? I mean I have seen him numerous times and each one hes looked like he is totally out of his depth and struggling. You put him next to a fit Woodgate and then you will realise what class actually is. With all due respect, how many games have you seen this season? The guy has been different gravy. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Acidmouse on January 20, 2011, 10:40:46 AM Collocini is pure class. There are so many "decent" centre halfs, trust me he is pure quality. Didn't say Ben Arfa was the best, but think he is in top 3. Looking through each position its clear the premiership isn't THAT GREAT. I stand by my pics though. I have always been against your Nolan stance, I dont for one min think he is a world class player, but for Newscastle he will score the goals that might make the difference come end of the season. But when someone tells me Collocini is class this really makes me question if you can see past the black and white blinkers? I mean I have seen him numerous times and each one hes looked like he is totally out of his depth and struggling. You put him next to a fit Woodgate and then you will realise what class actually is. With all due respect, how many games have you seen this season? The guy has been different gravy. Enough times to know I wouldn't say he is class. (or in anyones top 3 CB's! ffs) Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: boldie on January 20, 2011, 10:44:14 AM Collocini is pure class. There are so many "decent" centre halfs, trust me he is pure quality. Didn't say Ben Arfa was the best, but think he is in top 3. Looking through each position its clear the premiership isn't THAT GREAT. rotflmfao this might be the best post ever. BoB IMO Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 10:49:38 AM He's quick, good in the air, composed on the ball and fantastic in the air (espeically considering he is only 5"10 low centre of gravity ftw). A better version of Rio Ferdinand, he has a good relationship with his back four. He can be dirty when he needs to be, cheats when he needs to be, oh and he has fucking quality hair.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: boldie on January 20, 2011, 11:01:57 AM He's quick, good in the air, composed on the ball and fantastic in the air (espeically considering he is only 5"10 low centre of gravity ftw). A better version of Rio Ferdinand, he has a good relationship with his back four. He can be dirty when he needs to be, cheats when he needs to be, oh and he has fucking quality hair. this just keeps getting better and better. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 11:14:40 AM Did I mention he never misses a game? That he speaks at least 4 languages? Or that I want curly hair too?
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: TheChipPrince on January 20, 2011, 11:17:42 AM He's quick, good in the air, composed on the ball and fantastic in the air (espeically considering he is only 5"10 low centre of gravity ftw). A better version of Rio Ferdinand, he has a good relationship with his back four. He can be dirty when he needs to be, cheats when he needs to be, oh and he has fucking quality hair. I have no real opinion of how good he is as I rarely watch a newcastle game for 90mins, but do you not think someone, even a half decent Prem team would have snapped him up while you were in the Chamionship, either in the summer or in the Jan if he was 'exceptional'? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 11:29:36 AM He's quick, good in the air, composed on the ball and fantastic in the air (espeically considering he is only 5"10 low centre of gravity ftw). A better version of Rio Ferdinand, he has a good relationship with his back four. He can be dirty when he needs to be, cheats when he needs to be, oh and he has fucking quality hair. I have no real opinion of how good he is as I rarely watch a newcastle game for 90mins, but do you not think someone, even a half decent Prem team would have snapped him up while you were in the Chamionship, either in the summer or in the Jan if he was 'exceptional'? He had a porr first season (See Thierry Henry/Robert Pires) and last year he really worked out in the gym and got big. He crushed the championship (obv) but people hadn't seen him in the Premiership apart from his dubious first season. He has had a fantastic first 4/5 months and anyone who saw the game on Sunday will see that he kept 24m man Darren Bent in his back pot and was absolutely brilliant. I think the commentators tongue is still hanging out of his rear (next to mine) Oh Collocini you are the love of my life Oh Collocini I'd let you shag my wife Oh Collociniiii I want curly hair tooooo Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Madone on January 20, 2011, 12:15:45 PM I don't understand, all these newcastle players in your top 3 and there 9th in the league!
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 01:25:22 PM I don't understand, all these newcastle players in your top 3 and there 9th in the league! We have an awful goalkeeper, one striker, no rightback, no wingers (Ben Arfa broken leg) No attacking midfielder (Nolan's shite) we are slowly building a team that next season will be battling for Europe and within 5 years be champions of england if not Europe. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: boldie on January 20, 2011, 01:47:09 PM I don't understand, all these newcastle players in your top 3 and there 9th in the league! We have an awful goalkeeper, one striker, no rightback, no wingers (Ben Arfa broken leg) No attacking midfielder (Nolan's shite) we are slowly building a team that next season will be battling for Europe and within 5 years be champions of england if not Europe. rotflmfao. Pleno, I love you man..you're funnier than Bolt ever was. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Dubai on January 20, 2011, 02:06:19 PM I don't understand, all these newcastle players in your top 3 and there 9th in the league! We have an awful goalkeeper, one striker, no rightback, no wingers (Ben Arfa broken leg) No attacking midfielder (Nolan's shite) we are slowly building a team that next season will be battling for Europe and within 5 years be champions of england if not Europe. Will offer you a bet, il bet Newcastle get relegated next season, you bet they qualify for Champions League- anything else is a push Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 02:07:35 PM I don't understand, all these newcastle players in your top 3 and there 9th in the league! We have an awful goalkeeper, one striker, no rightback, no wingers (Ben Arfa broken leg) No attacking midfielder (Nolan's shite) we are slowly building a team that next season will be battling for Europe and within 5 years be champions of england if not Europe. Will offer you a bet, il bet Newcastle get relegated next season, you bet they qualify for Champions League- anything else is a push Battling for Europe is alot different than champions league. I'll have top 7 or qualifying through cup competition and you have relagation? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Dubai on January 20, 2011, 02:09:40 PM You can have top 7, and il have bottom 7
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 02:10:48 PM Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Dubai on January 20, 2011, 02:14:17 PM u want a price? You can have 6-4
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: The Camel on January 20, 2011, 02:15:31 PM 2-1 with me.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Dubai on January 20, 2011, 02:17:51 PM theres always one show off :)
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 20, 2011, 02:20:45 PM bidding wars ftw.. your next offer Dubai?
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: mondatoo on January 20, 2011, 05:03:39 PM I'd just like to say that Pleno's exaggerated at best,clueless at worse views are not representative of most Newcastle fans or at least any I know.Collocini is having a decent season and was immense on Sunday but he isn't in the top 10 CB's in the prem nevermind top 3 and obviously no Newcastle player is.Still think he maybe levelling when he describes him as better than Rio,lol.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: scotty2hatty on January 20, 2011, 06:29:52 PM Habib Beye???
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: sweet potata! on January 20, 2011, 06:37:28 PM If pleno is not levelling with every post he has made in the last week about football then he's obv clueless imo.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 20, 2011, 06:38:19 PM If pleno is not levelling with every post he has made in the last week about football then he's obv clueless imo. lol, agreed. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: claypole on January 20, 2011, 11:00:51 PM GK - Cech, Reina, Hart RB - Sagna, Hutton, Rafael LB - Cole, Boatang, Evra CB - Vidic, Ferdinand, Toure RW - Nani, Johnson, Nasri LW - Bale, N'Zogbia, Malouda DM - Essien, Parker, Toure AM - Van Der Vart, Lampard, Fabregas No 9 - Torres, Drogba, Carroll No 10 - Tevez, Van Persie, Ballotelli Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: The Baron on January 21, 2011, 12:51:56 AM More respeck for Kompany IMO
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: The Camel on January 21, 2011, 01:31:29 AM GK - Cech, Reina, Hart RB - Sagna, Hutton, Rafael LB - Cole, Boatang, Evra CB - Vidic, Ferdinand, Toure RW - Nani, Johnson, Nasri LW - Bale, N'Zogbia, Malouda DM - Essien, Parker, Toure AM - Van Der Vart, Lampard, Fabregas No 9 - Torres, Drogba, Carroll No 10 - Tevez, Van Persie, Ballotelli Ballotelli?????????????????????? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Madone on January 21, 2011, 02:17:04 AM Everyone seems to have Nani in there top 3 right midfielders, not sure i can agree with this, far to inconsistent imo, but he could well be and just shows how weak the premier league is the moment!
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 02:38:24 AM Lampard over Nasri :O
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: The Camel on January 21, 2011, 03:18:07 AM If you took a squad of the Premierships best players, gave them time to gell and make a team, maybe play some competitive matches, what price would you make them to beat Barca over two legs?
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: George2Loose on January 21, 2011, 10:08:07 AM Based on a mixture of form and ability. I know Given is probably a weird choice but I deffo think he is wasted on the Man City bench and am shocked no one has bought him yet.
GK - Given, Reina, Hart RB - Sagna, Bosingwa, Rafael LB - Cole, Baines, Evra CB - Vidic, Ferdinand, Jagelka RW - Nani, Milner, Nasri LW - Bale, Giggs, Malouda DM - Essien, Huddlestone, Fletcher AM - Van Der Vart, Lampard, Fabregas No 9 - Torres, Rooney, Tevez No 10 - Tevez, Van Persie, Ballotelli Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 10:57:13 AM Given's distribution and aerial ability makes him second rate imo.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: TightEnd on January 21, 2011, 11:57:15 AM I'll play and prepared to be shot down!
GK - Reina, Hart, Cech RB - Sagna, Rafael, Hutton LB - Cole, Evra, Clichy CB - Vidic, Terry, Kompany RW - Nasri, A Johnson, Modric LW - Bale, Malouda, Silva DM - Essien, A Song, YaYa Toure AM - Fabregas, Gerrard, Modric No 9 - Drogba, Torres, Van Persie No 10 - Tevez, Van Der Vaart, Rooney Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Dubai on January 21, 2011, 12:05:22 PM If you took a squad of the Premierships best players, gave them time to gell and make a team, maybe play some competitive matches, what price would you make them to beat Barca over two legs? Odds on Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: boldie on January 21, 2011, 12:08:12 PM If you took a squad of the Premierships best players, gave them time to gell and make a team, maybe play some competitive matches, what price would you make them to beat Barca over two legs? Odds on Really? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 12:16:31 PM Diaby >>>>>>>>> Alex Song (Defensive Mid)
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Josedinho on January 21, 2011, 12:36:43 PM I'm not having Yaya Toure as a DM.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 21, 2011, 12:43:14 PM If you took a squad of the Premierships best players, gave them time to gell and make a team, maybe play some competitive matches, what price would you make them to beat Barca over two legs? Cech Sagna, Vidic, Terry, Cole Nani, Essien, Fabregas, Malouda/Bale Tevez, Torres Valdes Alves, Puyol, Pique, Abidal Busquets/Mascherano Xavi, Iniesta Messi, Pedro Villa Going on these sort of sides, over 2 legs i'd go Prem XI 10/11, Barca Evs (tight bookies prices 4/5, 10/11) v close but Barcas defence is the issue which makes me swing this way. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Dubai on January 21, 2011, 12:45:02 PM If you took a squad of the Premierships best players, gave them time to gell and make a team, maybe play some competitive matches, what price would you make them to beat Barca over two legs? Odds on Really? Yes id say so comfortably. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: mondatoo on January 21, 2011, 12:45:47 PM Do you really think it's even close between Malouda and Bale ?
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 21, 2011, 12:47:33 PM Do you really think it's even close between Malouda and Bale ? Very for a prem XI side. There no Crouchy in there whos desperate for Bales crossing skills and Malouda better at passing the ball. I was hoping people would concentrate on Camel's question that the rough team effort tho tbh. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Dubai on January 21, 2011, 12:48:14 PM Diaby >>>>>>>>> Alex Song (Defensive Mid) [/quot This is wrong, ask any Arsenal fans and im sure they would tell u this Also people have short memories cos Thomas Vermaelen hasnt even got a mention yet and Brent how can Nasri not be in the prem XI? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: mondatoo on January 21, 2011, 12:54:17 PM Do you really think it's even close between Malouda and Bale ? Very for a prem XI side. There no Crouchy in there whos desperate for Bales crossing skills and Malouda better at passing the ball. I was hoping people would concentrate on Camel's question that the rough team effort tho tbh. I think you priced it up right and my thinking was they same as you regarding Barca's defence. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 12:56:10 PM wtf Horneis? Drogba > Torres AINEC.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: mondatoo on January 21, 2011, 12:57:00 PM Both at there peak I pick Torres everytime.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 12:59:07 PM Sorry meant, Drogba/Tevez >>>> Tevez/Torres
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 12:59:34 PM Valencia > Nani?
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 21, 2011, 01:01:50 PM Pleno, i don't discuss football with you anymore after you selected Collocini and Raul Meireles in the best 3 in their position in the prem.
I did say "these sort of sides". Camels Q is better than arguing about teams. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: TightEnd on January 21, 2011, 01:07:09 PM I'm not having Yaya Toure as a DM. AM or DM. Played DM mostly for Barca Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: maldini32 on January 21, 2011, 01:09:09 PM I reckon Barca would be more around the 8/11 mark.
Maybe its just my opinion that Barcelona are the best footballing team i have ever seen in my life (im 28). How many of the prem players would get into barca's team? There'd be more barca players in the prem team. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: maldini32 on January 21, 2011, 01:09:36 PM Diaby >>>>>>>>> Alex Song (Defensive Mid) Diaby is not a dm Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 01:17:11 PM Diaby >>>>>>>>> Alex Song (Defensive Mid) Diaby is not a dm Nor is Song? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: TightEnd on January 21, 2011, 01:19:39 PM Song deffo DM
Diaby either, usually AM For me Song is more important to Arsenal than Diaby is, allows the others to play Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 01:38:41 PM Hasn't Song been really attacking recently, seen him in the opposing area on countless occasions. I know Diaby sometimes plays upfront but much prefer him in the Veira role.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: GreekStein on January 21, 2011, 01:40:12 PM Just caught up with the thread.
Pleno, one thing mate, WHAT THE ABSOLUTE FUCK?! I'd rather have Brad Friedel in my team than Pepe Reina btw. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 01:41:46 PM Just caught up with the thread. Pleno, one thing mate, WHAT THE ABSOLUTE FUCK?! I'd rather have Brad Friedel in my team than Pepe Reina btw. Friedel has been gashhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh this season. I was levelling with Mereiles and Gyan. But deadly serious with Collocini. Collocini >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gary Cahill/Hangeland AINEANFC Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: GreekStein on January 21, 2011, 01:44:21 PM Just caught up with the thread. Pleno, one thing mate, WHAT THE ABSOLUTE FUCK?! I'd rather have Brad Friedel in my team than Pepe Reina btw. Friedel has been gashhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh this season. I was levelling with Mereiles and Gyan. But deadly serious with Collocini. Collocini >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gary Cahill/Hangeland AINEANFC Haven't watched a huge amount of football this season tbf as I'm so fked off with it and rather just watch Barca put on a performance when I can but Friedel has been pretty awesome every year he's been in the premiership imo. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Josedinho on January 21, 2011, 01:49:10 PM Diaby >>>>>>>>> Alex Song (Defensive Mid) This is wrong, ask any Arsenal fans and im sure they would tell u this Also people have short memories cos Thomas Vermaelen hasnt even got a mention yet and Brent how can Nasri not be in the prem XI? I'm not having Yaya Toure as a DM. AM or DM. Played DM mostly for Barca True but can't have him top 3 DM's in the prem when he's not played there. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 01:52:33 PM Just caught up with the thread. Pleno, one thing mate, WHAT THE ABSOLUTE FUCK?! I'd rather have Brad Friedel in my team than Pepe Reina btw. Friedel has been gashhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh this season. I was levelling with Mereiles and Gyan. But deadly serious with Collocini. Collocini >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gary Cahill/Hangeland AINEANFC Haven't watched a huge amount of football this season tbf as I'm so fked off with it and rather just watch Barca put on a performance when I can but Friedel has been pretty awesome every year he's been in the premiership imo. Yeah for sure, he used to be really good. But this season has shown he is definetely passed it. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 01:53:08 PM Diaby >>>>>>>>> Alex Song (Defensive Mid) [/quot This is wrong, ask any Arsenal fans and im sure they would tell u this Also people have short memories cos Thomas Vermaelen hasnt even got a mention yet and Brent how can Nasri not be in the prem XI? Diaby is bigger, blacker, meaner, faster, stronger, he is the new Veira woooahhhh Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: scotty2hatty on January 21, 2011, 05:40:33 PM Hasn't Song been really attacking recently, seen him in the opposing area on countless occasions. I know Diaby sometimes plays upfront but much prefer him in the Veira role. When did you see Diaby playing up top? Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: GrafhamGrinder on January 21, 2011, 06:41:28 PM pads..............
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2011, 06:53:02 PM who dis
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Madone on January 21, 2011, 09:52:56 PM I reckon Barca would be more around the 8/11 mark. Maybe its just my opinion that Barcelona are the best footballing team i have ever seen in my life (im 28). How many of the prem players would get into barca's team? There'd be more barca players in the prem team. barca's current side are the bestc club side ever, my old man been watching football for 50+ years now and he can't remember a better team, he is glued to the tv every game they play. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: The Baron on January 22, 2011, 01:14:27 AM I'll play and prepared to be shot down! GK - Reina, Hart, Cech RB - Sagna, Rafael, Hutton LB - Cole, Evra, Clichy CB - Vidic, Terry, Kompany RW - Nasri, A Johnson, Modric LW - Bale, Malouda, Silva DM - Essien, A Song, YaYa Toure AM - Fabregas, Gerrard, Modric No 9 - Drogba, Torres, Van Persie No 10 - Tevez, Van Der Vaart, Rooney Agree with almost all of this. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Madone on January 22, 2011, 01:33:48 AM I'll play and prepared to be shot down! GK - Reina, Hart, Cech RB - Sagna, Rafael, Hutton LB - Cole, Evra, Clichy CB - Vidic, Terry, Kompany RW - Nasri, A Johnson, Modric LW - Bale, Malouda, Silva DM - Essien, A Song, YaYa Toure AM - Fabregas, Gerrard, Modric No 9 - Drogba, Torres, Van Persie No 10 - Tevez, Van Der Vaart, Rooney Agree with almost all of this. Modric is that good he deserves 2 positions! Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 22, 2011, 01:48:52 AM Tiote > Essien BIC
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: boldie on January 22, 2011, 10:49:26 AM I reckon Barca would be more around the 8/11 mark. Maybe its just my opinion that Barcelona are the best footballing team i have ever seen in my life (im 28). How many of the prem players would get into barca's team? There'd be more barca players in the prem team. barca's current side are the bestc club side ever, my old man been watching football for 50+ years now and he can't remember a better team, he is glued to the tv every game they play. I'm the same, the only team I always watch is Barca at the moment. They are just phenomenal. Better than I remember the Ajax side with Litmanen and Co in 95 and better than Milan with V Basten and Co and better than the invinsible Arsenal squad who also played some incred footie. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 22, 2011, 01:58:13 PM Pleno, i don't discuss football with you anymore after you selected Collocini and Raul Meireles in the best 3 in their position in the prem. I did say "these sort of sides". Camels Q is better than arguing about teams. pleno knew. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 22, 2011, 03:45:24 PM pleno fkn knew.
Don't judge someone off 10 games BH. I know, I fkn know. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 22, 2011, 03:48:41 PM pleno fkn knew. Don't judge someone off 10 games BH. I know, I fkn know. lol, we knew he was good. (we backed him enough times for first goalscorer, lol) Seen him do really well in Champs League and for Portugal. But hasnt been good so far and definately isnt top AM's lol. But like you said, you were levelling with him anyways. Did play v well today though. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 22, 2011, 04:21:43 PM Pleno, i don't discuss football with you anymore after you selected Collocini and Raul Meireles in the best 3 in their position in the prem. I did say "these sort of sides". Camels Q is better than arguing about teams. pleno knew. pleno knew. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 22, 2011, 04:36:14 PM pleno fkn knew, he always fkn knows
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 22, 2011, 04:36:58 PM pleno fkn knew, he always fkn knows nah, you were levelling. I wouldnt have said tht. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 22, 2011, 04:39:29 PM pleno fkn knew, he always fkn knows nah, you were levelling. I wouldnt have said tht. How is it down there on level 2 bud. Up here on level 3 its fkn amazing. Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: ChipRich on January 22, 2011, 04:48:08 PM pleno fkn knew, he always fkn knows nah, you were levelling. I wouldnt have said tht. How is it down there on level 2 bud. Up here on level 3 its fkn amazing. level 9 here pal Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 23, 2011, 05:15:29 AM BH has gone very very quiet.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: Horneris on January 23, 2011, 10:10:20 AM Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 23, 2011, 04:10:30 PM feels sweet.
Title: Re: Top 3 in every position.. Post by: pleno1 on January 23, 2011, 11:28:57 PM "I thought he (Coloccini) was the stand out player today, he was brilliant in everything he did.
|