Title: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: Boba Fett on July 18, 2011, 09:07:39 AM Just interested in what people think in this.....
Assume UK casino standard Full Ring £1/2 cash game 5% rake capped at £5 for pots under £500, tipping encouraged etc. Min Buyin £40/No Max Games are run on a feeder system, there is the occasional short-stacker but most players buy in for £100-200 however the main table can quickly become deepstacked and players will start buying in for more than £200. Players in the game are generally "live" players as in they havent put in meaningful volume online ever, they havent invested much/any time on improving/developing strategy/getting coaching online. There is a lot of limp/calling, most players really want to see a flop, most players are stubborn stations postflop, there isnt much 3/4/5 betting pre, they play very exploitably and make basic mistakes (We all know the type surely?) Most regs and randoms in these games are recreational players. They are not pro's, they dont have a bankroll they use for poker outwith their life money and lots of the players are underrolled for playing these games regularly but they enjoy to gamble. There is a time limit on the game, it will finish at 5.30am no matter what unless the game has broken before this. This causes a visible effect of winners locking up their profits closer to the end and losers exponentially widening their ranges and increasing their aggression in most situations in an attempt to get out for the session as the time winds down. So in a game of this description we bring along Mr A. Hero - He has a £4k(20X100bb buy ins) bankroll that is exclusively used for these games and is separate from funds used for life expenses. He will regularly have an edge over the standard table in these specific games. He plays equally well short stacking <50bbs, playing 50-100bbs deep and playing 100+bbs deep So I think we can all agree that the deeper the effective stacks are for Mr A.Hero, the lower variance the game will be for this player putting him in an advantageous position? So Mr Hero should always strive to buy in to cover the table by this logic? So the point Im eventually leading to.... is there a point with Mr. Hero's BR for this game that he should not try to cover the biggest stack in the game as it is risking too much of the bankroll in 1 game? If there is someone in the game £4k deep then obv Mr. hero shouldnt put his whole roll at risk in 1 game so is there a guideline for the point in which the advantage gained by being deeper stacked is negated by the increased risk of ruin to the bankroll? ty Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: StuartHopkin on July 18, 2011, 09:17:09 AM Personally don't think Mr Hero is rolled to play at all.
However 'soft' the game is he only has 20 buy ins which just isn't enough. Start covering by buying in for £400 he has 10 buy ins and is on the road to ruin. Any more and a couple of flips and he is finished. However in theory if he is massively +ev in the games he has a better chance of going on an upswing before he goes on a down swing and maybe this will buffer his roll a bit. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: Boba Fett on July 18, 2011, 09:27:01 AM Personally don't think Mr Hero is rolled to play at all. However 'soft' the game is he only has 20 buy ins which just isn't enough. Start covering by buying in for £400 he has 10 buy ins and is on the road to ruin. Any more and a couple of flips and he is finished. However in theory if he is massively +ev in the games he has a better chance of going on an upswing before he goes on a down swing and maybe this will buffer his roll a bit. I agree, a bigger BR would be much safer by calculating buy ins on a 200bb or more basis and effectively buying in for half of a buy in at the start of games but the same question still applies. Say Mr Hero's roll is £10k (25x200bbs) and one night 1 or more players run up a stack that we want to cover. At which point does over-buying become too much of a risk to the BR? Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: kinboshi on July 18, 2011, 09:56:31 AM I agree that £10K+ sounds like a more sensible roll.
As to the question of covering the biggest stack, there has to come a point when the size of the biggest stack is excessive and places too great a percentage of the hero's bankroll at risk. He either needs to select a different game to play, or sit with an amount that doesn't necessarily cover the other stacks. If he's 200bbs deep, then he's still deep enough to play profitably and maximise the advantage he has over the other players. Good question, and one that's relevant to a lot of people on here - including me. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: bhoywonder on July 18, 2011, 12:03:38 PM That is a good question........
If they are bad n if I had that br...I wouldnt risk it.....I would buy in short....double or triple up and b done....but I guess ur looking or thinking of stacking the big stack bad player.....risk vs.reward. vs. Br.busto.... Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: dreenie on July 18, 2011, 02:19:01 PM You have totally lost me, however you are my only hero....
Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: Solaris on July 18, 2011, 02:21:26 PM Do people really think having a 20bi bankroll is that bad when you're playing in a live setting vs fish?
Obviously it's not optimal, but we're playing 100bb poker here against retards incapable of adjusting properly. We should expect downswongs obv, but if we're in control emotionally I don't think it's too bad. That said, given our bankroll I would never be buying in, in order to cover the fish - we simply aren't rolled for that. If the games ran more often where I live, I'd give this a go with a 20bi bankroll. I don't think you'd be in as much danger of busting as people seem to think... Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: EvilPie on July 18, 2011, 02:27:12 PM 20bi is plenty if you stick to 100bb buy ins and don't worry about covering any big stacks.
You may miss out on a few opportunities to stack people but the risk of going bust makes that a minor consideration. It's far better to stay in control and build the roll up to a level where you can buy in bigger and stay comfortable. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: mondatoo on July 18, 2011, 03:00:14 PM Yeah I don't think it that's bad, online 30 is enough but you'd rather have 50 to be comfortable, so for live 20 is ok but could go busto. GL Mr Hero.
Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: GreekStein on July 18, 2011, 08:32:09 PM Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: mondatoo on July 18, 2011, 08:35:53 PM You can grind nlhe cash with 30 bi's, would prefer 50 but it's not insane. You might run terrible and bust but not that likely ?? Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: GreekStein on July 18, 2011, 08:40:43 PM You can grind nlhe cash with 30 bi's, would prefer 50 but it's not insane. You might run terrible and bust but not that likely ?? Disagree. 30 bi isn't enough. The whole point of a BR is to not bust. If from 30 BI you can run bad and bust then it's not enough. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: mondatoo on July 18, 2011, 08:43:38 PM You can grind nlhe cash with 30 bi's, would prefer 50 but it's not insane. You might run terrible and bust but not that likely ?? Disagree. 30 bi isn't enough. The whole point of a BR is to not bust. If from 30 BI you can run bad and bust then it's not enough. I said in my 1st post you'd rather have 50 to be comfortable, loving the irony of you telling me about br management. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: GreekStein on July 18, 2011, 08:45:18 PM You can grind nlhe cash with 30 bi's, would prefer 50 but it's not insane. You might run terrible and bust but not that likely ?? Disagree. 30 bi isn't enough. The whole point of a BR is to not bust. If from 30 BI you can run bad and bust then it's not enough. I said in my 1st post you'd rather have 50 to be comfortable, loving the irony of you telling me about br management. I dont really think 50 is enough online but don't get your knickers in a twist. Also, not that ironic since I can't remember the last time my BR was smaller than yours. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: mondatoo on July 18, 2011, 08:48:05 PM You can grind nlhe cash with 30 bi's, would prefer 50 but it's not insane. You might run terrible and bust but not that likely ?? Disagree. 30 bi isn't enough. The whole point of a BR is to not bust. If from 30 BI you can run bad and bust then it's not enough. I said in my 1st post you'd rather have 50 to be comfortable, loving the irony of you telling me about br management. I dont really think 50 is enough online but don't get your knickers in a twist. Also, not that ironic since I can't remember the last time my BR was smaller than yours. Haha, I wear boxers, I know you can still fit happily in a pair but knickers are too uncomfortable for me. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: blonde17 on July 18, 2011, 11:57:21 PM Aspades
Simple... 5% ...FWIW never use/risk more than a max 5% of your poker bankroll in any one game on any given day, no matter how weak the opposistion . That way you will not get busted by a freak run of bad luck, or bad play. This may not be optimal and may seem a little cautious but, from my own experience over several years or to be more accurate over two decades of live cash game play inc PLO, it has served me well. SO...5% no matter what. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: Boba Fett on July 19, 2011, 12:17:28 AM Aspades So on a £10k roll if you busted a £200 buy in then a £400 buy in you would never reload in the same game no matter how soft it is? Seems overly nitty....Simple... 5% ...FWIW never use/risk more than a max 5% of your poker bankroll in any one game on any given day, no matter how weak the opposistion . That way you will not get busted by a freak run of bad luck, or bad play. This may not be optimal and may seem a little cautious but, from my own experience over several years or to be more accurate over two decades of live cash game play inc PLO, it has served me well. SO...5% no matter what. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: redarmi on July 19, 2011, 12:27:53 AM So let me get this right.....
You get your money in preflop with 100bb which represent 5% of your bankroll with AA and get called by KJo and get beat. You wouldn't want to rebuy and play some more against that guy and would go home??? seems sub optimal to me and that is being polite! Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: blonde17 on July 19, 2011, 12:37:26 AM Aspades So on a £10k roll if you busted a £200 buy in then a £400 buy in you would never reload in the same game no matter how soft it is? Seems overly nitty....Simple... 5% ...FWIW never use/risk more than a max 5% of your poker bankroll in any one game on any given day, no matter how weak the opposistion . That way you will not get busted by a freak run of bad luck, or bad play. This may not be optimal and may seem a little cautious but, from my own experience over several years or to be more accurate over two decades of live cash game play inc PLO, it has served me well. SO...5% no matter what. And it may well be, but I can only comment on my own experiences, feel free to risk more and GL Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: blonde17 on July 19, 2011, 12:42:25 AM So let me get this right..... You get your money in preflop with 100bb which represent 5% of your bankroll with AA and get called by KJo and get beat. You wouldn't want to rebuy and play some more against that guy and would go home??? seems sub optimal to me and that is being polite! Thanks for being polite. BUT......you keep reloading and pray he doesn`t get lucky several times and bust you completely. Again I didn`t say it was best, just said it has served me well. I found out very early on that when I had a 4K banroll and lost half of it on one day it shook my confidence a bit, so just kept everything within my own comfort zone, but feel free to take more risk and GL. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: gatso on July 19, 2011, 12:50:59 AM So let me get this right..... You get your money in preflop with 100bb which represent 5% of your bankroll with AA and get called by KJo and get beat. You wouldn't want to rebuy and play some more against that guy and would go home??? seems sub optimal to me and that is being polite! Thanks for being polite. BUT......you keep reloading and pray he doesn`t get lucky several times and bust you completely. Again I didn`t say it was best, just said it has served me well. I found out very early on that when I had a 4K banroll and lost half of it on one day it shook my confidence a bit, so just kept everything within my own comfort zone, but feel free to take more risk and GL. this makes no sense. you're going to buyin again in the future so how is waiting until tomorrow to put my next 5% on the table with as yet unknown oppos better than doing it today in a super soft spot? Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: redarmi on July 19, 2011, 12:56:23 AM I suppose if you are prone to tilt then it might make sense but if you are tiliting to that degree you probably shouldn't be playing seriously
Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: smashedagain on July 19, 2011, 12:56:57 AM Are you a full time pro blonde 17? I see exactly where you are coming from and know a lot of guys with your way of thinking. Not wanting to be an arse but if you look at the guys who have been around a while they all have a similar thinking and have out lasted the gamblers.
Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: blonde17 on July 19, 2011, 02:10:10 AM I suppose if you are prone to tilt then it might make sense but if you are tiliting to that degree you probably shouldn't be playing seriously I guess you are right but those that know who I am will know that TILT is not in my vocabulary. Like I said it works for me but won`t be everyones taste. Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: blonde17 on July 19, 2011, 02:14:25 AM Are you a full time pro blonde 17? I see exactly where you are coming from and know a lot of guys with your way of thinking. Not wanting to be an arse but if you look at the guys who have been around a while they all have a similar thinking and have out lasted the gamblers. Yep...been around a while, grinding out a livin in live games since 1985. Nothing spectacular but... not gone bust either.Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: smashedagain on July 19, 2011, 02:18:02 AM Are you a full time pro blonde 17? I see exactly where you are coming from and know a lot of guys with your way of thinking. Not wanting to be an arse but if you look at the guys who have been around a while they all have a similar thinking and have out lasted the gamblers. Yep...been around a while, grinding out a livin in live games since 1985. Nothing spectacular but... not gone bust either.Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: blonde17 on July 19, 2011, 02:30:09 AM Hardly "In his gang" but he knows me well ! LoL
Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: bhoywonder on July 19, 2011, 06:29:41 AM Hardly "In his gang" but he knows me well ! LoL Gotta respect "old school" Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: Manuel on July 19, 2011, 06:50:32 PM ?Do you have give notic in this games if you wanna leave and you has made the profit or can you leaf straight way? I sometimes see these and I think no vair fair.
regards, M Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: cambridgealex on July 19, 2011, 06:57:39 PM Lol Herbie, knew you'd love that
Title: Re: Cash Game Bankroll/Buy In Question Post by: smashedagain on July 19, 2011, 08:05:22 PM Lol Herbie, knew you'd love that lol. am half expecting you to set me up with fake account bit like manuel above. someone saying they follow me and cant believe how good i am (and obv i am gonna swallow it) |