Title: Maths Question Post by: bobAlike on January 15, 2012, 12:34:28 PM Having not studied Maths for well over 20 years my 12 year old lad asked me for some help with his homework.
The question is: Jen is y years old and her mother is 27 years older. Together their ages total 45 years. a. In terms of Jen's age, how old is her mother now? b. Form an equation in y and solve it to find Jen's age and her mother's age now. He knows the ages are 9 and 36 but is struggling with forming the equation and Im just brain dead today. Any help appreciated. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 15, 2012, 12:38:55 PM a) y + 27
b) y + (y+ 27) = 45 2y = 18 y = 9 And the mother is 36 based on a) Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: bobAlike on January 15, 2012, 12:43:32 PM a) y + 27 b) y + (y+ 27) = 45 2y = 18 y = 9 And the mother is 36 based on a) Tyvm Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: bobAlike on January 15, 2012, 12:58:12 PM One more please.
Question: Sonia is n years old now and Cynthia, her sister, is 2 years older. In 5 years time the sum of their ages will be 20. How old is Sonia now? How old will Cynthia be in 5 years time? Again he knows the answers but not the equations to get to the answers. Thanks Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 15, 2012, 01:04:35 PM In 5 years time:
n + (n+2) = 20 2n + 2 = 20 2n = 18 n = 9 (Sonia) Cynthia = 11 (n + 2) Now: 5 years earlier so Sonia is 4. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: bobAlike on January 15, 2012, 01:06:04 PM In 5 years time: n + (n+2) = 20 2n + 2 = 20 2n = 18 n = 9 (Sonia) Cynthia = 11 (n + 2) Now: 5 years earlier so Sonia is 4. Thanks again Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Jon MW on January 15, 2012, 01:07:11 PM sigh - was going to do some teaching but CF was too quick with just the answer
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: bobAlike on January 15, 2012, 01:08:18 PM sigh - was going to do some teaching but CF was too quick with just the answer Feel free to eloborate Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Jon MW on January 15, 2012, 01:12:30 PM sigh - was going to do some teaching but CF was too quick with just the answer Feel free to eloborate Knowing the answer means it doesn't really work after the fact But basically the formula is just constructed from the words. Take the words like age (n),her sister is two years older (so n+2) - you then build up the rest of the formula following the words so that = 20, then you take off 5 because that's in 5 years time. Like I suggested, it seems a bit obvious just spelling it out like that once you've seen the answer - people can kind of remember stuff by it being explained, but you really learn by working it out yourself. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: the sicilian on January 15, 2012, 01:15:03 PM This is fantastic.... Celticalike has got u to do his lads homework and he looks like a genius in his child's eyes... Nice moves bobo
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 15, 2012, 01:21:11 PM Has this one been done on here before?
I have a standard coin. But... it is biased to one side. We don't know which side, nor do we know the size of the bias. How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance? Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: bobAlike on January 15, 2012, 01:23:10 PM sigh - was going to do some teaching but CF was too quick with just the answer Feel free to eloborate Knowing the answer means it doesn't really work after the fact But basically the formula is just constructed from the words. Take the words like age (n),her sister is two years older (so n+2) - you then build up the rest of the formula following the words so that = 20, then you take off 5 because that's in 5 years time. Like I suggested, it seems a bit obvious just spelling it out like that once you've seen the answer - people can kind of remember stuff by it being explained, but you really learn by working it out yourself. I totally agree with your sentiments on learning. I just couldnt elaborate on it for my lad. Unbelievably I was kid genius at Maths and was put up for A level at 13. I just have not done anything significant in numbers since I was 18, 26 years ago. I used to love numbers and recently bought a book called 'Alex's adventures in number land' excellent read if anyone's interested. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: bobAlike on January 15, 2012, 01:24:14 PM This is fantastic.... Celticalike has got u to do his lads homework and he looks like a genius in his child's eyes... Nice moves bobo Lol, lad sitting next to me and knows his dads a fraud. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: AndrewT on January 15, 2012, 04:12:28 PM Has this one been done on here before? I have a standard coin. But... it is biased to one side. We don't know which side, nor do we know the size of the bias. How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance? Do the thing where you hide it in one hand and get someone else to guess which hand it is in. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 15, 2012, 04:24:25 PM Nope. Too many other factors for that to be 50/50.
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Jon MW on January 15, 2012, 05:06:00 PM Nope. Too many other factors for that to be 50/50. like what? Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: mulhuzz on January 15, 2012, 05:20:46 PM Nope. Too many other factors for that to be 50/50. one suspects you could take a Chernoff bound to determine which side is biased and then take a decent sample based on that bias....although I'm probably overegging it for a random question on a poker forum? :D Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 15, 2012, 05:48:01 PM write a number on it using a pen, maybe a green one. then ask someone to guess whether it's an odd or an even number. they'll probs get it right about 50% of the time
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: doubleup on January 15, 2012, 06:08:26 PM write a number on it using a pen, maybe a green one. then ask someone to guess whether it's an odd or an even number. they'll probs get it right about 50% of the time the date on the coin could be odd or even, so you wouldn't need to spend the coin to buy a green pen Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: mulhuzz on January 15, 2012, 06:28:44 PM Nope. Too many other factors for that to be 50/50. one suspects you could take a Chernoff bound to determine which side is biased and then take a decent sample based on that bias....although I'm probably overegging it for a random question on a poker forum? :D confirmed overegged it. sigh. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 15, 2012, 06:45:46 PM I figured the date thing would be biased to the last full year as there'd be more in circulation
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: EvilPie on January 15, 2012, 06:50:41 PM Rather than flip the coin just take it out of your pocket and place it on a table.
Assuming you don't know which way the bias works I'm pretty sure that'd be 50/50. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 15, 2012, 07:08:31 PM Or we could just flip it and call heads or tails. As we don't know what way it's biased it's still 50/50 whether we get it right or not
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: AndrewT on January 15, 2012, 07:27:30 PM Take the coin and throw it at cf's head. You'll either hit him or you won't - 50/50.
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: mulhuzz on January 15, 2012, 07:27:51 PM Or we could just flip it and call heads or tails. As we don't know what way it's biased it's still 50/50 whether we get it right or not nah - what if the coin is 100% biased? Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 15, 2012, 07:31:49 PM Or we could just flip it and call heads or tails. As we don't know what way it's biased it's still 50/50 whether we get it right or not nah - what if the coin is 100% biased? Even if it's double headed/tailed we're still 50/50 to get it right if we don't know which one. Ignorance ftw Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: mulhuzz on January 15, 2012, 07:35:36 PM ok, say 90% it's heads and 10% it's tails.
we pick heads 50% and tails 50% over 100 trials (assume no variance and that 100 is a big enough number to make results match expectation perfectly) when we pick tails, we're never right 50% of the time.... Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 15, 2012, 07:50:06 PM agreed but I'm only talking about a one off single flip
question asked 'How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance?' and that's what we'd get once Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 15, 2012, 08:30:59 PM agreed but I'm only talking about a one off single flip question asked 'How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance?' and that's what we'd get once Nope. You're making an assumption that neither person knows about the bias, and this might not always be the case. The correct answer will always work, no matter the bias (as long as it's not doublesided/100% of course). Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: doubleup on January 15, 2012, 08:51:13 PM Nope. You're making an assumption that neither person knows about the bias, and this might not always be the case. We don't know which side, nor do we know the size of the bias. How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance? So that was the royal we and not a co-operative effort from a pair of tossers? Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: kinboshi on January 16, 2012, 12:34:10 AM Use the coin to buy another one, or a dice, or a deck of cards.
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 16, 2012, 12:41:59 AM Nope. You're making an assumption that neither person knows about the bias, and this might not always be the case. no I'm not, you told us that Has this one been done on here before? I have a standard coin. But... it is biased to one side. We don't know which side, nor do we know the size of the bias. How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance? my answer is correct unless you want to move the goalposts Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Jon MW on January 16, 2012, 06:08:32 AM Has this one been done on here before? I have a standard coin. But... it is biased to one side. We don't know which side, nor do we know the size of the bias. How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance? Do the thing where you hide it in one hand and get someone else to guess which hand it is in. Is also correct. When CF says: Nope. Too many other factors for that to be 50/50. What he actually means is: Yes. But that's not the way I was thinking of. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 16, 2012, 06:41:20 AM Has this one been done on here before? I have a standard coin. But... it is biased to one side. We don't know which side, nor do we know the size of the bias. How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance? Do the thing where you hide it in one hand and get someone else to guess which hand it is in. Is also correct. When CF says: Nope. Too many other factors for that to be 50/50. What he actually means is: Yes. But that's not the way I was thinking of. This method only works if the person doing the hand holding is 100% unreadable. My solution can be mathematically proven. It's done by tossing the coin and observing the result. (hint: results). No trickery etc required. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 16, 2012, 12:01:30 PM you could just accept that there's more than one way to answer the question the way you worded it
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: DungBeetle on January 16, 2012, 02:24:29 PM Ask punter to call heads or tails (lets say he calls tails)
Toss coin twice. If it is a tails and then a tails then start again. If it is a heads and then a heads then start again If it is a heads and then a tails he loses If it is a tails and then a heads he wins The answer works for whatever bias the coin has, but lets assume it is 10% heads and 90% tails. Chances of HT = 9% Chances of TH = 9% By removing all other possibilities we have a total "chance population" of 18% and we now have a 50/50 proposition. When the guy calls the toss Tails he is in effect picking the Tails/Heads combo without knowing it and the other guy has the Heads/Tails combo. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: DungBeetle on January 16, 2012, 02:25:32 PM Ah - it pulled the old Ten of Hearts when I typed TH.
"Chances of Heads/Tails = 9% Chances of Tails/Heads = 9%" Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: doubleup on January 16, 2012, 03:32:45 PM in b4 cf gives a reason why this is wrong Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: DungBeetle on January 16, 2012, 03:41:50 PM I think it's mathematically sound, but I'm not sure if I am allowed to "kick out" toss observations like I have suggested.
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: mulhuzz on January 16, 2012, 03:54:55 PM good work. this is kinda like taking the C boundary but without all the expensive maths ;)
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 16, 2012, 07:11:00 PM That is indeed the answer :)
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: George2Loose on January 17, 2012, 12:47:54 AM worst thread ever
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 17, 2012, 12:58:06 AM Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: Cf on January 17, 2012, 06:50:57 AM just cos you didn't get the right answer ;) Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: kinboshi on January 17, 2012, 07:23:22 AM just cos you didn't get the answer I wanted, and instead gave another correct answer ;) FYP Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: rex008 on January 17, 2012, 09:58:56 AM That is indeed the answer :) This answer is based on a condition that isn't specified in the original question: What happens if the bias is 100%? The answer is only correct for bias < 100%. Very poorly worded question, so I agree with gatso. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: DungBeetle on January 18, 2012, 10:13:55 AM Still works for 100% bias. Both players have a 0% chance and the flips last forever, but theoretically both people still have the same chance of winning so it is "fair".
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: rex008 on January 18, 2012, 10:50:27 AM Has this one been done on here before? I have a standard coin. But... it is biased to one side. We don't know which side, nor do we know the size of the bias. How can we use this coin to get a genuine 50/50 chance? It's not a genuine 50/50 chance if it's 100% biased. You can't multiply 0 by anything to get to 50. 0/0 is indeterminate. My point stands :P. Edit: To clarify my point - if the question had said, "the same chance of winning", I would accept your response. But it doesn't. 50/50 ≠ 0/0. Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: DungBeetle on January 19, 2012, 01:32:58 PM Point conceded.
Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: rex008 on January 19, 2012, 03:17:47 PM Point conceded. Thanks, but are you sure you're on the right forum? This is blonde. People don't just concede points. I want an ARGUMENT, FFS :D Title: Re: Maths Question Post by: gatso on January 19, 2012, 04:44:53 PM Point conceded. Thanks, but are you sure you're on the right forum? This is blonde. People don't just concede points. I want an ARGUMENT, FFS :D it's alright, cf will be along in a bit to attach some random caveat that wasn't included in the original question |