blonde poker forum

Poker Forums => Poker Hand Analysis => Topic started by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 10:30:24 AM



Title: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 10:30:24 AM
$400 nl holdem prelim event here in Dublin. I have 19k in the small blind and average is 22k. 49 runners left out of 150 and 18 is the $$$$. I have a good table image but not afraid to play! ( actually a tight image for me, was very quiet). We have 9 players at the table.

Have been at the same table for 7 hours , inbetween the same two "good" players. I feel I have the respect of both players as I have played well.

Blinds are 600/1200 w/ 100 ante,  folds to the buttom  and he raises to 4,400 and I find  2h 2s in the small blind, I think for a short while and move all in  :blonde: ?

Button takes a long time to think and then says "lets gamble". He has  As Th and its a race (he had 17k in chips).

My question is should I have raised to lets say 11k to get this guy to think???? Does the all in here show weakness???? I dont want to play  2c 2h post flop, do you even play this hand????

Rookie on his way to his 1st EPT title on Sunday


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: byronkincaid on October 28, 2005, 10:41:04 AM
stop n go if no A comes on the flop.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TightEnd on October 28, 2005, 10:43:53 AM
i think the all in is wrong...ok he might just be making a standard button move but you are potentially risking your whole tournament life on a race when you have no need to

A flat call is no option to me here, who wants to play 22 post flop out of position?

for you, the fold probably feels too tight against a button raise

i think a raise to 10k plus gives the button the message that you have something you want to play, looks stronger than an all-in, and he folds anything but premium hands. After all, he respects you. He may even re-raise you pre-flop witha biggie  and you can escape.

 If he doesn't fold and you get a raggy flop you can push post flop I suppose if you put him on high cards
 


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: winkie on October 28, 2005, 10:48:59 AM
Mr Rookie sir... personally I would not have played this hand. I absolutely hate looking down and finding a small pocket pair (when I'm playing poker that is....)

Always found it one of the hardest hands to play.

But then again, maybe that's why I'm not quite up there mixing it with the pros....


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: ifm on October 28, 2005, 11:42:32 AM
i would never play this hand as strongly as this, for me it's a straight choice:-

fold.....it only cost 600, no probs
call......try to flop the set or outplay him on the flop (my favourite, though depends on the amount of any raise), i check call most bets on the flop here (scares the bejesus out of most players :D)


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 11:47:49 AM
I think the 10k was the way to go, I knew iI had made a mistake right after I made the "move". He hit the  Td on the flop, it was a  Td high flop so i may have busted anyway, so I was down to 2k and quickly off to bed. DC still had good chips so I hope he finished well!!!!

Great input, keep it coming 8)


I would like more ideas and comments on this hand, this is what Blonde is all about!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 11:49:29 AM
Mr Rookie sir... personally I would not have played this hand. I absolutely hate looking down and finding a small pocket pair (when I'm playing poker that is....)

Always found it one of the hardest hands to play.

But then again, maybe that's why I'm not quite up there mixing it with the pros....

The pros are players just like you, trying to find the right mix to win 8) That is what is great about poker!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 11:52:37 AM
A bracelet winner asking the blolndeites for hand advice - only on blonde!

Give it a  while Rookie, Flushy & Ironside will put you right.......

xx


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: AdamM on October 28, 2005, 11:55:14 AM
easy pass for me
with 2,2 I might get a late position first eaise in or limp into a family pot for a set but I'm almost never calling a raise or re raising with them. but then I'm a rock and you're a maniac.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 11:57:12 AM
i would never play this hand as strongly as this, for me it's a straight choice:-

fold.....it only cost 600, no probs
call......try to flop the set or outplay him on the flop (my favourite, though depends on the amount of any raise), i check call most bets on the flop here (scares the bejesus out of most players :D)

NEVER, never say never, I made a move w/ a made hand, I agree and I wish I would have played it different, I do not agree w/ calling in this position at all, I dont want to enter the hand w/ 25% of my chips saying to myself that I can pass if I dont hit a set, outplay him after the flop is a possibility but I dont like that idea in this hand, I consider this a good player ( point to think about for me), if I raise I always have the extra option of a pass pre-flop.

as it turns out the  Tc on the flop just ends the conversation, hell it was 50% / 50% and I had a chance

I guess it was a move that did not work, I just should have made a better move :blonde:


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TightEnd on October 28, 2005, 11:58:51 AM
it's an easy pass for me, but then I'm not as aggressive as Brian


if you accept he doesn't want to pass to a button raise, which could be any handl

I think a raise to 10k is far far more preferable to a flat call if you IGNORE THE PASS..discuss


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 12:02:28 PM
I have made a small grammatical edit to Rookie's post to remove a stray  As that appeared, & which destroyed the context of a sentence.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:06:43 PM
easy pass for me
with 2,2 I might get a late position first eaise in or limp into a family pot for a set but I'm almost never calling a raise or re raising with them. but then I'm a rock and you're a maniac.

Thanks for the shirt, great stuff.

There is 6,500  in the pot, almost 33% of my stack, I have played very few hands in the 30 minutes leading to this hand, I needed to pick up a pot at some time. Other players at the table are stealling like mad, you must start playing at this point!!!!!!!!!  But maybe this was not the hand :blonde:

Earlier in the comp I was in the small blind and called a button rise of 500 when blinds were 100/200 w 2h 4c, flop  2s 4d and I busted the guy w/  Ah As, you must learn to gamble at the right times 8)

I thought you were just trying to put a rock image across in the heads up when you beat me, know I find you really are 8)


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:08:02 PM
it's an easy pass for me, but then I'm not as aggressive as Brian


if you accept he doesn't want to pass to a button raise, which could be any handl

I think a raise to 10k is far far more preferable to a flat call if you IGNORE THE PASS..discuss

I think I should have bet 11,300     


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: byronkincaid on October 28, 2005, 12:10:41 PM
so are you going all in on any flop if the guy calls your raise?


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:16:19 PM
so are you going all in on any flop if the guy calls your raise?

yes,  I move it in and hope for the best, down to 7k or so, he better have a hand, but just in this case against this player at this time, not always


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TightEnd on October 28, 2005, 12:16:45 PM
any rag flop, probably


maybe


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:18:33 PM
any rag flop, probably


maybe

even if he has me on the flop I once again give him every chance to pass, if not I have 2 outs and I hope for the best, I want to win the comp and the chips are moving fast around me


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TightEnd on October 28, 2005, 12:19:35 PM
gotcha



Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:22:45 PM
that may be me biggest problem, I needed to give him more than one chance to pass, allin does not do that, reraise and even play after the flop does!

as it turns out he probaly wont because he hits his  Td, to me thats just unlucky for me, but I am looking at this hand as a way to become a force at the table again and have a chance to win!

My stack has gradually gone down from 32k in 2 hours and I need to stop the bleeding!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: ifm on October 28, 2005, 12:25:15 PM
what was the turn?
i call the original raise, flat call a bet (other than a huge one) on the flop, if a bigger card hits the turn he's gonna slow down, then i push.
If the turn is a J Q or K he will fold.
That is what i meant by outplaying him on the flop


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: The Baron on October 28, 2005, 12:26:23 PM
Sorry to be different but I think you've made quite a good move here. I really cant see how he's managed to call with A10!

He's announced "let's gamble" so I guess he read you correctly for an underpair but why couldn't you have had AQ or AK?

Ok in hindsight your move with 22 was maybe a little too risky but it still doesn't explain how the hell he made such a good call.

I guess some of it is who you make the move against and this guy was obviously good enough to call in the right spot. If you'd turned over AK though he'd have looked silly.

Mate, the truth is you should start playing real hands - like 2 3 of spades!  8)


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:30:17 PM
what was the turn?
i call the original raise, flat call a bet (other than a huge one) on the flop, if a bigger card hits the turn he's gonna slow down, then i push.
If the turn is a J Q or K he will fold.
That is what i meant by outplaying him on the flop

I got that, dont remember, didnt care, tired after 7 hours of play, you have good points, the table had become an all in fest and I think I got trapped into that idea, something I will work on in my game! 


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:33:05 PM
Sorry to be different but I think you've made quite a good move here. I really cant see how he's managed to call with A10!

He's announced "let's gamble" so I guess he read you correctly for an underpair but why couldn't you have had AQ or AK?

Ok in hindsight your move with 22 was maybe a little too risky but it still doesn't explain how the hell he made such a good call.

I guess some of it is who you make the move against and this guy was obviously good enough to call in the right spot. If you'd turned over AK though he'd have looked silly.

Mate, the truth is you should start playing real hands - like 2 3 of spades!  8)

It was Mick ?, great guy who writes for Pokereuropa out of Ireland, good player, table was graet, had some new bullies on it also w/ 2 other top players! He made a very good call!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 12:36:38 PM
Rookie says "Mick", it's Mick McCloskey. How on earth he makes that call with A-T I don't know!

as for Rookie, I just can't get over a Bracelet Winner - American at that - actually having the humility to seek hand advice on here, & admitting he MAY have played it wrong. Top bloke. Needs to wear socks though.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:37:12 PM
what was the turn?
i call the original raise, flat call a bet (other than a huge one) on the flop, if a bigger card hits the turn he's gonna slow down, then i push.
If the turn is a J Q or K he will fold.
That is what i meant by outplaying him on the flop

I know this guy moves, or calls w/ any part of the board post flop, he is getting short as I am, I am relly tring to find a way to get him off any non-premium hand pre-flop, that is how I was thinking at the time, if he has the goods than good luck to him the rest of the way.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:40:34 PM
Rookie says "Mick", it's Mick McCloskey. How on earth he makes that call with A-T I don't know!

As for Rookie, I just can't get over a Bracelet Winner - American at that - actually having the humility to seek hand advice on here, & admitting he MAY have played it wrong. Top bloke. Needs to wear socks though.

great guy, I really enjoyed playing w/ him, I think he was very impressed w/ my changing gears, I played one of my best no-limit comps ever, to bad I did not get a result for it, he really understands how the rookie plays and how much fun it is to be at the rookies table.

 


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: The Baron on October 28, 2005, 12:46:06 PM
what was the turn?
i call the original raise, flat call a bet (other than a huge one) on the flop, if a bigger card hits the turn he's gonna slow down, then i push.
If the turn is a J Q or K he will fold.
That is what i meant by outplaying him on the flop

I know this guy moves, or calls w/ any part of the board post flop, he is getting short as I am, I am relly tring to find a way to get him off any non-premium hand pre-flop, that is how I was thinking at the time, if he has the goods than good luck to him the rest of the way.

Exactly, and to give him the BEST opportunity to pass (if you decide to move here, personally I wouldn't have) I think the all in is the correct play. It gives MAXIMUM opportunity to pass.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 12:48:03 PM

Right Rookie, forget this 2-2 business, I got a problem for YOU to solve.

The Final of the €400 is this afternoon at 3pm. Dave is BIG Chip Leader, & Thewy is average. We NEED to get some sort of Live Update goling, & I am stuck at home here in Derbyshire.

So.......

Can you EITHER find a big Norweigan Guy called Rolf Woods & get him to call me, Dave has my number. Rolf is a big mate, we help each other a lot on Live Updates, & I know he will run a Live Update for us if you can find him for me.

Or....

Find someone to ring or text me with Updates from the Final this afternoon.

Off you go then - you sorted it yet?


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 12:50:33 PM
great news, i will get it done


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 12:55:30 PM
Brian, if you get this sorted, I'll go easy on you next time we share a table.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Junior Senior on October 28, 2005, 01:06:18 PM
fold!

growl and stare at the raiser, mutter something about this being the last time he messes with your blinds and tell him you hate laying down a big hand like this. - then muck... and continue to muck with similar holdings until you find a proper hand with which to go to war.


remember its all about  4c 7d


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: jezza777 on October 28, 2005, 01:55:35 PM
I like the move and indeed you were ahead. Calling is absolutely out of the question in my opinion you are clearly pot commited, a reraise does look to be a stronger move but the opponent must realise you will commit to any flop. So in short any move you make here commits you for all your chips. With 22 this not a situation I would want to be in . So I think a fold here and pray for a better opportunity , you still have enough to make people pass and nick some blinds and you are coming into blind stealing territory position wise.
Still max kudos for the move, the move of a aggressive champion :)up . I have no idea where he found a call from with A 10 .

just my thoughts


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 02:05:33 PM
fold!

growl and stare at the raiser, mutter something about this being the last time he messes with your blinds and tell him you hate laying down a big hand like this. - then muck... and continue to muck with similar holdings until you find a proper hand with which to go to war.


remember its all about  4c 7d

thank you to the king of the hill


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 02:07:34 PM
I like the move and indeed you were ahead. Calling is absolutely out of the question in my opinion you are clearly pot commited, a reraise does look to be a stronger move but the opponent must realise you will commit to any flop. So in short any move you make here commits you for all your chips. With 22 this not a situation I would want to be in . So I think a fold here and pray for a better opportunity , you still have enough to make people pass and nick some blinds and you are coming into blind stealing territory position wise.
Still max kudos for the move, the move of a aggressive champion :)up . I have no idea where he found a call from with A 10 .

just my thoughts

that may have been the problem I saw, I was getting middle of the pack and I didnt know If i would get this chance again, thanks for the insight


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 02:10:34 PM
To me this is the heart of blonde, I dont care if I ever sound or look stupid to anyone ( just ask Junior) but the point is experience and knowledge is the source of power 8)

Please, I want to see more posts, I want everyone to post something, there is no wrong answer 4h 7d


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: dazla996 on October 28, 2005, 02:31:16 PM
i think i would of folded this hand, or called and if i didnt hit on the flop, fold..simple,,


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: lvlarc_uk on October 28, 2005, 02:58:17 PM
Easy fold.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: dan on October 28, 2005, 03:07:47 PM
i fold or go all in, i dont think a reraise would put him off and then you are committed anyway


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TightEnd on October 28, 2005, 03:58:13 PM
a re-raise might put a junk button raise off

and most people wouldn't have called the all in with A 10 anyway, and wouldn't call the re-raise there with A10...it looks stronger than the all-in.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 28, 2005, 04:05:28 PM
Call is not an option.

Folding is an option but i don't like it.

Raise, this is my preferd option, the question is how much.

Against a respnable player i move in, so make it a 15k bet into a 8k pot and let him decide if he wants to continue, this is still a big enough bet to get him to lay down (another reason for doing this, i don't want to wait a round and be in the situation when i have 17k and someone has raised 6k and now i can't get them to pass)

Against a good opponent i make it 10k more, give him 2-1 on the call to see a flop, he will then realise you are dying for action and have to pass a good hand.

How you were called by AT here is beyond me, i think it is a horrible call, risking your life on AT to a re-raise is pure madness. He was probably praying you just had a small pair. If you turn over AJ AQ AK he is in a world of pain and lets face it those are the 3 aces you are re-raising with in this spot.


You were unlucky you ran into a bad call and then lost the 50-50, that is poker as they say.

If he had laid down AT then you would have been on 25k and have a chance to steal a little without cripling yourself, a well timed move, just a pity the raiser never got sent the script.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TightEnd on October 28, 2005, 04:07:32 PM
Call is not an option.

Folding is an option but i don't like it.

Raise, this is my preferd option, the question is how much.

Against a respnable player i move in, so make it a 15k bet into a 8k pot and let him decide if he wants to continue, this is still a big enough bet to get him to lay down (another reason for doing this, i don't want to wait a round and be in the situation when i have 17k and someone has raised 6k and now i can't get them to pass)

Against a good opponent i make it 10k more, give him 2-1 on the call to see a flop, he will then realise you are dying for action and have to pass a good hand.

How you were called by AT here is beyond me, i think it is a horrible call, risking your life on AT to a re-raise is pure madness. He was probably praying you just had a small pair. If you turn over AJ AQ AK he is in a world of pain and lets face it those are the 3 aces you are re-raising with in this spot.


You were unlucky you ran into a bad call and then lost the 50-50, that is poker as they say.

If he had laid down AT then you would have been on 25k and have a chance to steal a little without cripling yourself, a well timed move, just a pity the raiser never got sent the script.

Perfect answer. I took five posts to say that, and not as precisely as he did


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 04:08:04 PM
Never thought I'd say this, but I agree with every word of Flushy's analysis. He may make a half-decent player one of these days.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: byronkincaid on October 28, 2005, 04:14:06 PM
Everyone's saying calling is not an option but i don't understand why a stop n go isn't a good move here. I hate being stopped and goed, if you can tell me some way around it I'll be very grateful.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 28, 2005, 04:18:32 PM
Everyone's saying calling is not an option but i don't understand why a stop n go isn't a good move here. I hate being stopped and goed, if you can tell me some way around it I'll be very grateful.

You are not short enough for a stop and go to be optimal.

Say for example he raised with J8s, to steal the blinds, now the flop comes J83, 873, J96 or any combination of that sort of flop, you move in and he is calling. If you raise pre flop you take the pot away from J8.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: lvlarc_uk on October 28, 2005, 04:21:15 PM
Flushy why do you think it was a terrible call with Ace 10 ? Maybe he deserves credit for putting him on a low pair?


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: jezza777 on October 28, 2005, 04:21:50 PM
Call is not an option.

Folding is an option but i don't like it.

Raise, this is my preferd option, the question is how much.

Against a respnable player i move in, so make it a 15k bet into a 8k pot and let him decide if he wants to continue, this is still a big enough bet to get him to lay down (another reason for doing this, i don't want to wait a round and be in the situation when i have 17k and someone has raised 6k and now i can't get them to pass)

Against a good opponent i make it 10k more, give him 2-1 on the call to see a flop, he will then realise you are dying for action and have to pass a good hand.

How you were called by AT here is beyond me, i think it is a horrible call, risking your life on AT to a re-raise is pure madness. He was probably praying you just had a small pair. If you turn over AJ AQ AK he is in a world of pain and lets face it those are the 3 aces you are re-raising with in this spot.


You were unlucky you ran into a bad call and then lost the 50-50, that is poker as they say.

If he had laid down AT then you would have been on 25k and have a chance to steal a little without cripling yourself, a well timed move, just a pity the raiser never got sent the script.



 :goodpost:    Absolutely spot on mate. I do think the reraise is a stronger move or at least scarier to your foe than an all in. However he must know that you cannot fold on any flop so the chances are that they would read it as an all in, and do whatever they were going to do anyway.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 28, 2005, 04:37:51 PM
Flushy why do you think it was a terrible call with Ace 10 ? Maybe he deserves credit for putting him on a low pair?

No noubt he put Brian on a 'range'

This range would have included PP's from QQ-22, although he knows it's more likley the 88-QQ. Also the face aces, AK AQ AJ. It drives me mad when players say "i put you on a small pair" because the small pair is played the same as AK AQ AJ here, i.e. all in.

So to call with AT, you are hoping it's the small pair rather than the pair, and i can't name many world class players calling off thier stacks hooping that they are just a slight dog.

An arguement could be made that if you know a player well you may know he is liable to push back with A9/A8 etc, however Brian said he had been playing tight and i don't think he has much of a reputation in Ireland given that i don't think he has played there before!!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 04:43:03 PM

Yes Flushy, The Rookies first trip to Ireland, & he told me this morning he'd been sitting very quiet, & had not played a hand in half an hour.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 28, 2005, 05:00:20 PM
Maybe mr AT had somewhere to go?

I do love it when people know they are making bad calls and say "let's gamble" to sort of justify it, lol.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TEXAS_JAY on October 28, 2005, 05:08:28 PM
mmmm...Obviously not knowing whats comin on the flop, I'd have just called to see what the flop brought me and if there wasn't a  2 then i'd have just check,checked all the way but if he/she had called after the flop,turn or river then i'd have folded. But please don't take any advise from me, believe me..I'm more of a rookie than you. Goodluck on sunday m8.      TJ


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: The Baron on October 28, 2005, 05:24:49 PM
Everyone's saying calling is not an option but i don't understand why a stop n go isn't a good move here. I hate being stopped and goed, if you can tell me some way around it I'll be very grateful.

You are not short enough for a stop and go to be optimal.

Say for example he raised with J8s, to steal the blinds, now the flop comes J83, 873, J96 or any combination of that sort of flop, you move in and he is calling. If you raise pre flop you take the pot away from J8.

Precisely. The stop and go cant really work if he has a nicking hand. Brian obviously thought he was.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 05:32:16 PM
Call is not an option.

Folding is an option but i don't like it.

Raise, this is my preferd option, the question is how much.

Against a respnable player i move in, so make it a 15k bet into a 8k pot and let him decide if he wants to continue, this is still a big enough bet to get him to lay down (another reason for doing this, i don't want to wait a round and be in the situation when i have 17k and someone has raised 6k and now i can't get them to pass)

Against a good opponent i make it 10k more, give him 2-1 on the call to see a flop, he will then realise you are dying for action and have to pass a good hand.

well said, thanks for the opinion

How you were called by AT here is beyond me, i think it is a horrible call, risking your life on AT to a re-raise is pure madness. He was probably praying you just had a small pair. If you turn over AJ AQ AK he is in a world of pain and lets face it those are the 3 aces you are re-raising with in this spot.


You were unlucky you ran into a bad call and then lost the 50-50, that is poker as they say.

If he had laid down AT then you would have been on 25k and have a chance to steal a little without cripling yourself, a well timed move, just a pity the raiser never got sent the script.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 05:34:37 PM
Flushy why do you think it was a terrible call with Ace 10 ? Maybe he deserves credit for putting him on a low pair?

I spoke to micky today and he said I could make that move because he thought I would STOP a stael that way, but it was his comp life on the line!!!!!!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 05:37:50 PM
Flushy why do you think it was a terrible call with Ace 10 ? Maybe he deserves credit for putting him on a low pair?

No noubt he put Brian on a 'range'

This range would have included PP's from QQ-22, although he knows it's more likley the 88-QQ. Also the face aces, AK AQ AJ. It drives me mad when players say "i put you on a small pair" because the small pair is played the same as AK AQ AJ here, i.e. all in.

So to call with AT, you are hoping it's the small pair rather than the pair, and i can't name many world class players calling off thier stacks hooping that they are just a slight dog.

An arguement could be made that if you know a player well you may know he is liable to push back with A9/A8 etc, however Brian said he had been playing tight and i don't think he has much of a reputation in Ireland given that i don't think he has played there before!!

I played "rookie Poker" u ntil rebuys were done, then I played the tightest of my life because I had 32k and wanted to pick my spots well, it was noy called because I had a bad table image, but the guy was very familiar w/ me and my story


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 05:39:42 PM
mmmm...Obviously not knowing whats comin on the flop, I'd have just called to see what the flop brought me and if there wasn't a  2 then i'd have just check,checked all the way but if he/she had called after the flop,turn or river then i'd have folded. But please don't take any advise from me, believe me..I'm more of a rookie than you. Goodluck on sunday m8.      TJ

great post, I want advise from everyone, I mean everyone, then I will take it all in and make my own judgement, the more input the better


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 05:41:57 PM

But Rookie, WHATS THE NEWS FROM THE €400 Final?


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 28, 2005, 05:58:43 PM
OK so he knew who you were, but you had been playing tight, so surely he must have taken this into account. Having said that you say you were playing tight, but is that tight or is it "rookie tight"??


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 06:14:59 PM

But Rookie, WHATS THE NEWS FROM THE €400 Final?

Sorry, DC out in 4th, big hand all in pre flop w/ DC holding  Ah Jd, other guy   Ac 8c, DC ahead after flop , turn  8d, end of story


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 06:18:06 PM
OK so he knew who you were, but you had been playing tight, so surely he must have taken this into account. Having said that you say you were playing tight, but is that tight or is it "rookie tight"??

I really had a great night going, had not shown any B S hands at all, no  4s 7c, he just wanted to gamble, thought I just made a move because I put him on a steal. I had the right balance between aggresion and tightness, but I felt I really needed a pot soon, the big stacks were getting bigger and bigger.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 28, 2005, 06:20:54 PM
After further review I think the only mistake I made was the all in, I should have bet 10k - 12.5k, that would have worried him more and maybe killed his willingness to "gamble".

Rookie off to the $100 rebuy here in Dublin, seeya 8)


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 28, 2005, 06:27:24 PM
Brian please bring us back another Gem of a hand to discuss.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: robyong on October 28, 2005, 06:37:01 PM
Right move by you, wrong call by him.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: The Baron on October 28, 2005, 06:41:13 PM
Amen.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 28, 2005, 06:49:50 PM
Right move by you, wrong call by him.

7 words in a perfect post.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: ifm on October 28, 2005, 07:07:45 PM
what if he had KK?
then it isn't a good move is it?
I still would have called despite all the views.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: 12barblues on October 28, 2005, 10:58:25 PM
****FISH ALERT*****

Although I'm up against the big guns here, I really don't understand the view that a re-raise is the answer. My thinking is:

1. A fold is fine - but you need to win a hand in the next orbit and a half or you are the target for everyone;

2. A call with a view to folding unless you hit your set is awful. The odds just aren't there to try for a 7.5 to 1 shot;

3.A call intending to outplay him after the flop out of position with next to nothing when you think he's good? No thanks.

3. A call intending a stop and go....hmmmm......need to do some more research/thinking about this one, but my gut feel is that if he's on a steal he has two cards to hit on the flop against your one, and all his are better than yours. In addition, no-one has mentioned the possibility of the BB having a hand worth a call when he's getting good odds;

4.A re-raise to 10k/11k/12.5k? Who are you kidding with a 19k stack? You are pot-committed surely? He's getting 3 to 1 at 10k which is very tempting unless he puts you on premium cards only (and I think news of the WSOP will have reached Eire by now.......). I think all the money is going in either pre-flop or on the flop. Given that, an all in is surely preferable?

In summary, I think folding and praying for a genuine big hand is ok, as is the all-in. It's a toss up.

Flame away, tell me why I'm an idiot, I want to learn!

12bb


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 11:20:33 PM

Thats a GREAT analysis too, 12bb. We have had several, but this is up there amongst them imo.


Rookie is playing this evening, but he will respond to this, & the others, as soon as he gets back to the Hotel. He really does appreciate this interchange of ideas.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: 12barblues on October 28, 2005, 11:36:56 PM
Tikay,

Ty.  I was more nervous about posting this than you would believe!

 My 'fish alert' comment was not false modesty, unfortunately.

12bb


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 28, 2005, 11:49:46 PM

12bb. I am no expert at hand analysis, but I thought you showed great logic & reasoning, I really did. I bet the Rookie agrees.

I was a tad unsure about "3" - "he has 2 outs to hit on the flop" - he does of course have SIX outs, but he has to hit them.

We'd appreciate more hand analysis from you, we really would. You express yourself very well, if you don't mind me saying so.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: 12barblues on October 29, 2005, 12:05:48 AM
When I said '2 cards to hit', I meant (in the J8 example earlier) that he could hit a J (3 cards) or an 8 (3 cards), being 6 in total. In other words, the chances of hitting a 2 (er....2 in total) are much worse* i.e. we agree.

*Your phrase 'a tad unsure' is the politest way i've ever heard anyone say 'what a load of b******s'  ;D

12bb


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 29, 2005, 12:25:36 AM
The reason for raising less than al-in is to give the impression of a much stronger hand, everyone knows if you raise to 10k it's as good as all in, however it says 'i have a hand, i want you in the pot'



Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: 12barblues on October 29, 2005, 12:39:04 AM
But not when you are clearly pot committed.....I think we are into the area of double-double-counterdouble-bluffs here as to whether a smaller raise means more strenghth or less.

 It all depends on your read of the other person. I remain convinced this is a 'sh*t or bust' situation. If you are in, you are in for your whole stack at some point. If you don't fancy that, fold.

12bb

PS Can anyone explain (because I can't) why I'm arguing with a bracelet holder and all the big guns on this site.......other than to say I'm an obstinate sod  >:?

Some people don't know when they're beaten  :hello:


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 29, 2005, 12:52:21 AM
12bb, that is exactly the point.

You are commited, they know and you know it, but you have made it 'seem' cheaper, making them think you have a MASSIVE hand.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: dan on October 29, 2005, 12:55:25 AM
flushie i know and agree with what you are saying but do you think that if the head case that called with A10 wouldnt call the raise or even go over the top.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on October 29, 2005, 12:59:36 AM
You never know, its like a stop and go, it probably wont make much diffrence, but it just might....those times it does increase the edge of a winning player that little bit more.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on October 29, 2005, 01:02:13 AM
"head case". Mick McCluskey a head case. Absolutely not. Ahem.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TEXAS_JAY on October 29, 2005, 01:02:52 AM
 :goodpost:
Good debate..learnt alot from just that one question. Anymore simular situations like this, please post em. Muchly appreciated. n1 wsopin06.   TJ    :)up


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: 12barblues on October 29, 2005, 01:23:31 AM
I've just written an extremely long ( and brilliantly argued) response to those who don't accept my views......and its disappeared into cyberspace  :(

If you find said brilliant post on some other thread (or other site  :o ) please put it back where it belongs  ;D


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:47:19 AM
Brian please bring us back another Gem of a hand to discuss.

thought that was easy, anytime


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:49:29 AM
****FISH ALERT*****

Although I'm up against the big guns here, I really don't understand the view that a re-raise is the answer. My thinking is:

1. A fold is fine - but you need to win a hand in the next orbit and a half or you are the target for everyone;

2. A call with a view to folding unless you hit your set is awful. The odds just aren't there to try for a 7.5 to 1 shot;

3.A call intending to outplay him after the flop out of position with next to nothing when you think he's good? No thanks.

3. A call intending a stop and go....hmmmm......need to do some more research/thinking about this one, but my gut feel is that if he's on a steal he has two cards to hit on the flop against


your one, and all his are better than yours. In addition, no-one has mentioned the possibility of the BB having a hand worth a call when he's getting good odds;



thanks for the post , well done

4.A re-raise to 10k/11k/12.5k? Who are you kidding with a 19k stack? You are pot-committed surely? He's getting 3 to 1 at 10k which is very tempting unless he puts you on premium cards only (and I think news of the WSOP will have reached Eire by now.......). I think all the money is going in either pre-flop or on the flop. Given that, an all in is surely preferable?

In summary, I think folding and praying for a genuine big hand is ok, as is the all-in. It's a toss up.

Flame away, tell me why I'm an idiot, I want to learn!

12bb


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:51:24 AM
The reason for raising less than al-in is to give the impression of a much stronger hand, everyone knows if you raise to 10k it's as good as all in, however it says 'i have a hand, i want you in the pot'



wheni did it i thought and then dismissed this, that is 1 reason i asked for the input


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:52:13 AM
Tikay,

Ty.  I was more nervous about posting this than you would believe!

 My 'fish alert' comment was not false modesty, unfortunately.

12bb

you cant help anyone, not even yourself, if you dont post


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:53:54 AM
But not when you are clearly pot committed.....I think we are into the area of double-double-counterdouble-bluffs here as to whether a smaller raise means more strenghth or less.

 It all depends on your read of the other person. I remain convinced this is a 'sh*t or bust' situation. If you are in, you are in for your whole stack at some point. If you don't fancy that, fold.

12bb

PS Can anyone explain (because I can't) why I'm arguing with a bracelet holder and all the big guns on this site.......other than to say I'm an obstinate sod  >:?

Some people don't know when they're beaten  :hello:

i dont agree, w/ the big comps bull shit wins sometimes, and it may stink mbut i will use it if it helps me win


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:56:17 AM
flushie i know and agree with what you are saying but do you think that if the head case that called with A10 wouldnt call the raise or even go over the top.

head case is a good educated player, but we all make a mistake and very every so often, the real questioon is how do i get him to pays and the answer may be nothing but the debate is great


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:58:08 AM
You never know, its like a stop and go, it probably wont make much diffrence, but it just might....those times it does increase the edge of a winning player that little bit more.

this is what i have come away w/ make as many ????????? as possible for the caller, not cut and dry!!!!!!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 03:59:46 AM
"head case". Mick McCluskey a head case. Absolutely not. Ahem.

no, very good player, I may have waited to long for this move, i may have been short enogh, shit, me short on chips or balls, bull shit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: ifm on October 29, 2005, 04:33:30 AM
i fail to see how you are out of position? it does not apply here


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: TheJagster on October 29, 2005, 09:08:36 AM
This has been one of the most useful and informative posts ive read for a long long time.

Thanks to wsopin06 and to the 'analysers'

In saying this I would have folded I rekkon and waited to make a move later in the circuit. OK there was a potential (never more than that) steal but if not and ur called you are in the poo and if you get a dodgy call (as possibly happened) you are as well.

OK maybe I am a wimp but if I could have played this with an escape route retaining chips I would have done. In these circumstances however I would have thought about the tourney survival implications and bailed out I think.

Right then back too my $5 stt!   lol


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Rachman on October 29, 2005, 03:32:02 PM
well i might as well throw in my views.

personally, i don't see the point of a 12k raise. you and he both know your pot committed, might as well just move all-in.

But what about a little minimum raise? another four thousand chips in would make him think. building the pot or just trying to re-steal without risking too many chips? depends on your image really. If he reraises then you still have the option of folding, sure 10k left isnt much but the blinds have just gone round so you have some time. If he calls then it makes it easier for him to fold on the flop if he misses (unlikely but easier) but it also gives you some chance of getting away if the flop looks nasty. Of course you'd prefer him to fold, and although an extra 4k to put in to call doesnt seem much compared to the pot, it is a third of his remaining stack, so it would depend on his views on the building or restealing question. its easier to keep playing with 13k than 9k.

Its worked for me at the end of a few tournies, although my upper limit is $50 really (unless i'm feeling particularly lucky), so it might not apply.

however, i agree with a fair few other people, i'd grab my balls and move all-in.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 29, 2005, 07:32:19 PM
well i might as well throw in my views.

personally, i don't see the point of a 12k raise. you and he both know your pot committed, might as well just move all-in.

But what about a little minimum raise? another four thousand chips in would make him think. building the pot or just trying to re-steal without risking too many chips? depends on your image really. If he reraises then you still have the option of folding, sure 10k left isnt much but the blinds have just gone round so you have some time. If he calls then it makes it easier for him to fold on the flop if he misses (unlikely but easier) but it also gives you some chance of getting away if the flop looks nasty. Of course you'd prefer him to fold, and although an extra 4k to put in to call doesnt seem much compared to the pot, it is a third of his remaining stack, so it would depend on his views on the building or restealing question. its easier to keep playing with 13k than 9k.

Its worked for me at the end of a few tournies, although my upper limit is $50 really (unless i'm feeling particularly lucky), so it might not apply.

however, i agree with a fair few other people, i'd grab my balls and move all-in.

thanks


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: dan on October 29, 2005, 09:36:44 PM
"head case". Mick McCluskey a head case. Absolutely not. Ahem.
flushie i know and agree with what you are saying but do you think that if the head case that called with A10 wouldnt call the raise or even go over the top.

head case is a good educated player, but we all make a mistake and very every so often, the real questioon is how do i get him to pays and the answer may be nothing but the debate is great

i used the term loosely and i apologise. he is a good player the point i was trying to make is that it was a slightly mad call with the A10. i was just trying to point out that i dint think he actually would of folded to a reraise.

oops i hope i havent offended mr McClusky or anybody else with that statement  :blonde:


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on October 30, 2005, 03:16:49 AM
"head case". Mick McCluskey a head case. Absolutely not. Ahem.
flushie i know and agree with what you are saying but do you think that if the head case that called with A10 wouldnt call the raise or even go over the top.

head case is a good educated player, but we all make a mistake and very every so often, the real questioon is how do i get him to pays and the answer may be nothing but the debate is great

i used the term loosely and i apologise. he is a good player the point i was trying to make is that it was a slightly mad call with the A10. i was just trying to point out that i dint think he actually would of folded to a reraise.

oops i hope i havent offended mr McClusky or anybody else with that statement  :blonde:

never, no one will take your post that way, your point is valid, keep them coming, thanks

rookie


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: The Headcase on October 31, 2005, 11:09:13 PM
Hi Brian and the rest of you guys. Tikay mentioned this big debate to me and I thought I would take a look. Very interesting.
Just to put things in context I would explain that calling a raise with  As Td is very much not my usual style. In this situation everyone passed to me on the button. I may have raised in this spot with any two cards but I actually had a legit raising hand. Brian's all-in re-raise looked kinda like "I know you are stealing on the button and I am gonna re-steal " I have made this move myself in the past. If you are prepared to make this move you can do it with any two cards. Therefore when I called I thought I  may  well have the best hand, if I had read the situation right. Even against any pair 9's or under I am only a very small underdog. Its the usual race situation and you gotta win your races to win tournaments. At some stage you gotta gamble. this is why I decided that this may well be the time.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: ifm on October 31, 2005, 11:10:31 PM
LOVE the choice of user name! ;D
Welcome to the madhouse


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: 12barblues on November 01, 2005, 01:48:39 AM
Nice one Mr. H. Case!

Would a smaller raise have been more effective in persuading you that you were facing a big hand rather than a re-steal? Or were you calling anyway?


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on November 01, 2005, 03:15:43 AM
Nice name!!!

Still not sure i like the call, lol.


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: wsopin07 on November 01, 2005, 09:41:56 AM
Nice name!!!

Still not sure i like the call, lol.

but what the heck, it made for a good debate here on blonde, wonder if I can submit my entry fee as a bill and have blonde pay me as the offical "fish" columnist!!!!!!!  8)


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: The Headcase on November 01, 2005, 03:05:34 PM
Nice one Mr. H. Case!

Would a smaller raise have been more effective in persuading you that you were facing a big hand rather than a re-steal? Or were you calling anyway?
Yes. I think a small re-raise or even a call would have set the alarm bells ringing. The small re-raise looks like he wants a call. The all in move looks like he does not. If he had called the game was up as I was not going to lay down top pair, top kicker after the flop, no matter what.
The Headcase


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: 12barblues on November 01, 2005, 05:26:33 PM


Now we have the definitive answer. Take a bow, Tightend and Flushy  :respect:

But the best thing in the whole 7 page thread was this:

To me this is the heart of blonde, I dont care if I ever sound or look stupid to anyone ..... but the point is experience and knowledge is the source of power 8)

Please, I want to see more posts, I want everyone to post something, there is no wrong answer





Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on November 01, 2005, 07:13:29 PM
I comend Mick for coming on and posting in this thread!!!

I am just glad i am not the one who called him a headcase!!!!  :D :D :D :D


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: dan on November 01, 2005, 09:00:30 PM
"head case". Mick McCluskey a head case. Absolutely not. Ahem.
flushie i know and agree with what you are saying but do you think that if the head case that called with A10 wouldnt call the raise or even go over the top.

head case is a good educated player, but we all make a mistake and very every so often, the real questioon is how do i get him to pays and the answer may be nothing but the debate is great

i used the term loosely and i apologise. he is a good player the point i was trying to make is that it was a slightly mad call with the A10. i was just trying to point out that i dint think he actually would of folded to a reraise.

oops i hope i havent offended mr McClusky or anybody else with that statement  :blonde:

i have a feeling i know why you chose your alias, please see my apology above  :-[ :-[


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: dan on November 01, 2005, 09:04:23 PM
I am just glad i am not the one who called him a headcase!!!!  :D :D :D :D

alright flushie no need to remind him :D


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: Royal Flush on November 01, 2005, 09:22:13 PM
Of course there is!!


Title: Re: How did I play this hand / comments please / from the ROOKIE!
Post by: tikay on November 01, 2005, 10:47:06 PM
This is blonde, remember your manners guys. It's MR HeadCase.