no its not meant to be damning
they just play more test cricket, are physically fitter/conditioned with great equipment playing on covered pitches that drain well. its a different game
he's 32 and has played 140 tests
lots of countries want to play england because of the revenue they bring, so England never rest
he could take off the odd winter tour, play for another 5 years and still hit 200 tests
top 10? off the top of my head
Bradman
Lara
Richards
Sachin
Compton
Hutton
G Chappell
Border
Hammond
Ponting
and i will have missed some
Cook isn't in the same postcode as any of those
He's in the same bracket as Gooch, boycott, Gower etc
Fair enough. Pretty similar points of view to me then. How high can Root get potentially on the all time list? Not just runs (obviously he could get to number 1 on that list easily) but where does his style/flair on top of the runs put him potentially in that all time list if he carries on to 32/33 like Cook has. He seems to have a great mental approach to the game/life so there is no reason to think he will go off the boil other than captaincy ruining him.
Surely Root is streets ahead in terms of talent.... just needs to prove himself over a decade or so which is never a given.