A couple of lads in my office swear by OLBG.com (they punt at a very recreational level and seem to use it for sports they have little personal insight into).
I never could get past the fact that the site is horrible, but it does seem to have a decent level of traffic.
Have no view on the "value" or success of the tips though.
That's the key thing Mr Crater needs to look out for, do they shows "audited" results, as TfT always has?
BE show their results, too.
If I were looking for the best site to follow, that's the first thing I'd look for.