Title: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: suzanne on December 08, 2006, 05:18:02 PM Ive just been reading an article on msn that suggests it is and to be honest it does look a bit fishy.
It suggests that Simon Cowell's voice coaches were grooming Leona BEFORE the auditions. It also says there is footage of Eton Road and Ray rehearsing together that suggests he was originally in the band and that the band was manufactured. Also this clip http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVq_g9NyQUM would suggest that Simon Cowell has known Anthony Hannah (the spooky one in Eton Road) for at least 3 years. I think my dreams of one day being "discovered" have just been shattered :-( Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Colchester Kev on December 08, 2006, 05:19:33 PM It will be a fix if Leona doesnt win it :)
Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: suzanne on December 08, 2006, 05:22:19 PM It will be a fix if Leona doesnt win it :) I agree totally but does it not scream of a set-up if she was being coached BEFORE the auditions? Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Jim-D on December 08, 2006, 05:27:19 PM It will be a fix if Leona doesnt win it :) I agree totally but does it not scream of a set-up if she was being coached BEFORE the auditions? She's been trying to make it as a singer for years and dont people get voice coached to help them do that? Nothing wrong with a rookie singer getting coached IMO Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: thetank on December 08, 2006, 05:30:48 PM I've lost 50 quid so yes, it must be a fix.
Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: suzanne on December 08, 2006, 05:32:35 PM It will be a fix if Leona doesnt win it :) I agree totally but does it not scream of a set-up if she was being coached BEFORE the auditions? She's been trying to make it as a singer for years and dont people get voice coached to help them do that? Nothing wrong with a rookie singer getting coached IMO Yes... but it was Simon Cowells voice coaches who were helping her. Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: suzanne on December 08, 2006, 05:34:44 PM I've lost 50 quid so yes, it must be a fix. Let me guess......The MacDonald brothers rotflmfao rotflmfao rotflmfao Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Royal Flush on December 08, 2006, 06:12:49 PM Eh?
I am confused how can the show be fixed? I don't watch it but my understanding is its a reality show (tosh) where they choose a singer to give a contract too. Is that right? Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Indestructable on December 08, 2006, 06:17:37 PM rather than a fix, i think it is set up to give a certain performer the best chance to win whetehr down to coaching or fashion etc, but utlimately down to the viewers/voters.
Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Colchester Kev on December 08, 2006, 06:18:39 PM Casino Casino .... now THAT was a fix !! :D
Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Royal Flush on December 08, 2006, 06:19:06 PM rather than a fix, i think it is set up to give a certain performer the best chance to win whetehr down to coaching or fashion etc, but utlimately down to the viewers/voters. Surely that's the point of the show though Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: suzanne on December 08, 2006, 08:46:47 PM rather than a fix, i think it is set up to give a certain performer the best chance to win whetehr down to coaching or fashion etc, but utlimately down to the viewers/voters. Yes I think perhaps this is a better way of putting it. The point I am trying to make Flushy is that we are led to believe that all the contestants are your average Joe Bloggs who have just walked in off the streets...this is obviously not the case. Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Ironside on December 08, 2006, 08:54:39 PM we have never been led to beleive that 99.99999% of the acts that make it to the final 100 have walked in off the streets most have been trying to have a carear in the industry for a number of years
tank you should of gotten out when i did i cleared £10 profit but laying off before last weeks show Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: kinboshi on December 08, 2006, 08:57:05 PM That professional wrestling is a fix I reckon... :dontask:
Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Ironside on December 08, 2006, 09:00:52 PM That professional wrestling is a fix I reckon... :dontask: dont be silly the undertaker rules Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Royal Flush on December 08, 2006, 09:02:55 PM we have never been led to beleive that 99.99999% of the acts that make it to the final 100 have walked in off the streets most have been trying to have a carear in the industry for a number of years exactly the best are already going to have had some training. Do you really think they audition all those people? Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Ironside on December 08, 2006, 09:07:10 PM no there team audition them and send up the best and worst one to be seen by the judges
most auditionees wont even see the 3 judges Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: tantrum on December 08, 2006, 09:25:21 PM This is a tv series which is produced by Simon Cowell who has some bussiness deal with BMG/SONY who in turn will offer some £ 1 million worth of record deal (fully recoupable of course).
It is rather self evident that this programme, although based on public voting, is set to influence and manipulate the audience. Genius money spinning idea. Nothing more nothing else. The way they choose songs/clothes for the contestants is not accidental and can be crucial in a voting numbers. It is like saying that Big Brother or other reality shows do portray pple as close to reality as possible. Media manipulation for public entertainment. Do we really care if those guys were coached before or not? Most of them don't have much talent anyway, they all look to me like karaoke pub singers, but mind you, most of the so called hits are sung by bland, lacking in personality and talent wierdos. ( am i getting old? hmm perhaps) ;tk; Leona is the only one now who has some potential as a singer, let's just hope that sony/bmg won't make her into some sing a long artist. If she loses it will be better for her anyway, as then she can pick better deal for herself and be more in control of her destiny. If she wins, she will have to slave away for at least a year and do as told, which considering what Cowel has done so far in the music industry this might screw her for a while.] Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Jim-D on December 08, 2006, 09:29:00 PM This is a tv series which is produced by Simon Cowell who has some bussiness deal with BMG/SONY who in turn will offer some £ 1 million worth of record deal (fully recoupable of course). It is rather self evident that this programme, although based on public voting, is set to influence and manipulate the audience. Genius money spinning idea. Nothing more nothing else. The way they choose songs/clothes for the contestants is not accidental and can be crucial in a voting numbers. It is like saying that Big Brother or other reality shows do portray pple as close to reality as possible. Media manipulation for public entertainment. Do we really care if those guys were coached before or not? Most of them don't have much talent anyway, they all look to me like karaoke pub singers, but mind you, most of the so called hits are sung by bland, lacking in personality and talent wierdos. ( am i getting old? hmm perhaps) ;tk; Leona is the only one now who has some potential as a singer, let's just hope that sony/bmg won't make her into some sing a long artist. If she loses it will be better for her anyway, as then she can pick better deal for herself and be more in control of her destiny. If she wins, she will have to slave away for at least a year and do as told, which considering what Cowel has done so far in the music industry this might screw her for a while.] :goodpost: Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Snatiramas on December 11, 2006, 10:51:29 AM If she wins, she will have to slave away for at least a year and do as told, which considering what Cowel has done so far in the music industry this might screw her for a while.]
Don't you mean that Simon might screw her for a while Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: AndrewT on December 11, 2006, 12:09:27 PM I thought there was a very interesting comment from Girls Aloud on Jonathan Ross's show on Friday when they said that Louis Walsh still earns money from them even though he has absolutely nothing to do with them any more.
Leona has quite clearly been the chosen one from the beginning which, personally, I have no problem with as she is far and away the most talented contestant in it. Cowell knows this and knows she should be a huge, long-term star, rather than a 'flash in the pan' act like Gareth Gates or a 'You look like that guy that won X-Factor - can I have a Big Mac and fries please' act like the middle-aged smarm Steve Somethingorother. She's also been in the business for a while - here's two promo videos she did in 2004. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1R4YS3CmB2w (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1R4YS3CmB2w) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJnpjip-iek (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJnpjip-iek) Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: tantrum on December 11, 2006, 12:13:27 PM Quote Don't you mean that Simon might screw her for a while nope I said this not him. I don't think he is capable of such acts. This is my opinion, only mine, and might not be true. Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Snatiramas on December 12, 2006, 08:10:22 AM Quote Don't you mean that Simon might screw her for a while nope I said this not him. I don't think he is capable of such acts. This is my opinion, only mine, and might not be true. I would have to say tho that I have seen rabid dogs slobber less Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Acidmouse on December 12, 2006, 12:35:50 PM I thought there was a very interesting comment from Girls Aloud on Jonathan Ross's show on Friday when they said that Louis Walsh still earns money from them even though he has absolutely nothing to do with them any more. He says he picks some of their songs they release/record,. he continues to leech from them for 5 years after they were formed. Least it pays for him and his boyfriends expensive lifestyle. Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: AndrewT on December 12, 2006, 12:46:33 PM Least it pays for Title: Re: Is X Factor a fix ? Post by: Poppet7 on December 12, 2006, 02:20:33 PM X factor isn't a fix... but they do manipulate the public...
Strictly come dancing is a FIX! Grrrrrrrrrr!! |