Title: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: George2Loose on January 21, 2010, 08:54:58 PM OK Me and Kev been discussing this one.
Live comp £40 plus 1 rebuy. Blinds a 200/400/50. We're 7 handed. Kev has circa 5k. He looks down at KJ off 2nd to act. In order what would u do? Raise to 1k Shove Fold Call Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Longy on January 21, 2010, 09:01:08 PM His position on the table would make a lot of difference here. Though it is a shove from all late positions.
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: The_duke on January 21, 2010, 09:02:21 PM all in - but thats just me (-_-)
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Longines on January 21, 2010, 09:06:04 PM Shove
Raise Fold Call Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: AlexMartin on January 21, 2010, 09:43:11 PM op's order, and obv never folding.
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: neverbluff67 on January 21, 2010, 10:00:33 PM SHOVE
FOLD RAISE TO 1K CALL Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: pleno1 on January 21, 2010, 10:15:52 PM SHOVE
FOLD 1K CALL Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: GreekStein on January 21, 2010, 11:51:18 PM Shove Raise Fold Call Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: thetank on January 21, 2010, 11:55:40 PM meh, this isn't an auto-shove when 2nd to act
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Longy on January 21, 2010, 11:59:18 PM It is a shove but it is pretty close.
Also calling is obv the worst option by a mile. Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: AndrewT on January 22, 2010, 12:10:01 AM How are there antes in the rebuy period?
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: thetank on January 22, 2010, 12:17:06 AM rebuy. I'm pretty sure the full stop is a full stop and not crazy shorthand for period Andrew. Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Free_Rollin on January 22, 2010, 03:02:35 AM Shove
Fold Raise Call Much rather fold, than raise or call. Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Blatch on January 22, 2010, 03:12:51 AM I went for: -
Fold Shove Raise Call Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: JaffaCake on January 22, 2010, 03:27:30 AM Fold
Shove Make it a lump Cut off my left testicle Call Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: NigDawG on January 22, 2010, 04:42:21 AM shove ainec?
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Royal Flush on January 22, 2010, 05:19:41 AM Shove, i wouldn't do the other 3 any % of the time.
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: paulhouk03 on January 22, 2010, 05:49:19 AM Shove, i wouldn't do the other 3 any % of the time. fold shove raise call It depends who is on the blinds too and what stacks they have + the other stack sizes behind you also. If its a total crapshoot then probs shove Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: NigDawG on January 22, 2010, 06:02:50 AM Shove, i wouldn't do the other 3 any % of the time. fold shove raise call It depends who is on the blinds too and what stacks they have + the other stack sizes behind you also. If its a total crapshoot then probs shove lol we have 12bb and a king and a jack arrrrr in Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Longy on January 22, 2010, 08:57:27 AM Fwiw sngwiz likes shoving based on cEV on average you gain approx 100 chips by shoving as opposed to folding. This isn't a very range sensitive spot and making opponents tight or loose makes not too much difference.
Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: TheChipPrince on January 22, 2010, 09:44:09 AM Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: ALASKAN5IVE on January 22, 2010, 11:12:46 AM this Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: outragous76 on January 22, 2010, 11:38:23 AM in a live game this def depends on stack sizes and WHO is in the blinds - i really think there is a huge void in comprehension of shove-botting between old school and more modern thinkers
but id go for fold shove raise call (never) Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: George2Loose on January 22, 2010, 05:47:23 PM OK my order was:
Shove Fold Raise to 1k Call Kev's was: Raise to 1k Fold Shove (which he thinks is awful btw) Call I personally think folding/shoving are both close but would usually get them in here. Consequently he raised to 1k, tight nit from a local game called with KQ and the flop came K22 Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: EvilPie on January 22, 2010, 06:24:45 PM Well you're not getting called by much worse unless there's a big stack in the blinds and you've been very active nicking.
You maybe get weak aces to pass by nits and KQ may have laid down depending on his stack and nittiness. This all depends on how active you've been but if you think every hand that beats KJ is calling and every hand losing to KJ is folding then this is effectively an atc shove anyway. Obviously KJ has loads more 50 50 potential against pairs which will call so we much prefer KJ there but then again atc has more bink potential against hands like AJ, AK and KQ so they might even offset each other. So if you've been active nicking then this is a shove because you may get called by worse. If you've been inactive it's a shove no matter what you've got because people will fold better and you build a reputation to get called later when your KJ or similar is actually ahead. Hmmmm...... I've just read this back and it might possibly make no sense. I don't care though because at least I know what I mean. I've noticed that I haven't mentioned the words raise, call or fold here so I guess that's my option 1 Shove (pretty much always) Raise (only if I think someone may shove weaker) Fold (don't think I could though) Call (possibly if I've been setting someone up with a couple of limp folds earlier but this would be uber rare and require several other factors to fall in to place) Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: kinboshi on January 22, 2010, 06:52:24 PM Well you're not getting called by much worse unless there's a big stack in the blinds and you've been very active nicking. You maybe get weak aces to pass by nits and KQ may have laid down depending on his stack and nittiness. This all depends on how active you've been but if you think every hand that beats KJ is calling and every hand losing to KJ is folding then this is effectively an atc shove anyway. Obviously KJ has loads more 50 50 potential against pairs which will call so we much prefer KJ there but then again atc has more bink potential against hands like AJ, AK and KQ so they might even offset each other. So if you've been active nicking then this is a shove because you may get called by worse. If you've been inactive it's a shove no matter what you've got because people will fold better and you build a reputation to get called later when your KJ or similar is actually ahead. Hmmmm...... I've just read this back and it might possibly make no sense. I don't care though because at least I know what I mean. I've noticed that I haven't mentioned the words raise, call or fold here so I guess that's my option 1 Shove (pretty much always) Raise (only if I think someone may shove weaker) Fold (don't think I could though) Call (possibly if I've been setting someone up with a couple of limp folds earlier but this would be uber rare and require several other factors to fall in to place) ...and they say Hopkin is a tosser. Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: Longy on January 22, 2010, 07:04:01 PM Well you're not getting called by much worse unless there's a big stack in the blinds and you've been very active nicking. You maybe get weak aces to pass by nits and KQ may have laid down depending on his stack and nittiness. This all depends on how active you've been but if you think every hand that beats KJ is calling and every hand losing to KJ is folding then this is effectively an atc shove anyway. Obviously KJ has loads more 50 50 potential against pairs which will call so we much prefer KJ there but then again atc has more bink potential against hands like AJ, AK and KQ so they might even offset each other. So if you've been active nicking then this is a shove because you may get called by worse. If you've been inactive it's a shove no matter what you've got because people will fold better and you build a reputation to get called later when your KJ or similar is actually ahead. Hmmmm...... I've just read this back and it might possibly make no sense. I don't care though because at least I know what I mean. I've noticed that I haven't mentioned the words raise, call or fold here so I guess that's my option 1 Shove (pretty much always) Raise (only if I think someone may shove weaker) Fold (don't think I could though) Call (possibly if I've been setting someone up with a couple of limp folds earlier but this would be uber rare and require several other factors to fall in to place) Nah it makes sense which is why it is mathematically correct push and ranges don't really matter. If we only get called by better hands, we have crap load of FE and pick up the bliinds enough to compensate for getting it in bad. Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: BulldozerD on January 22, 2010, 08:22:27 PM Fold
Shove Raise lol call obv top 2 fairly close and depends what table is like Title: Re: Settle a simple argument for me Post by: GreekStein on January 22, 2010, 08:33:10 PM Yeah but have you seen his tax bill!?
|