blonde poker forum

Poker Forums => The Rail => Topic started by: david3103 on October 19, 2011, 11:13:35 AM



Title: Ruling query
Post by: david3103 on October 19, 2011, 11:13:35 AM
Self-deal at the new;y opened G Stockton last night.

Idiot dealer* deals the flop before one player has called the preflop raise

It is suggested that we burn and deal turn, burn and deal river then shuffle and redeal flop

TD/Cardroom Manager/Supervisor is called and rules the player who hadn't acted's hand dead

We're told this is standard in G Cardrooms?





* Me  ;booboo;



Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: Karabiner on October 19, 2011, 11:46:33 AM
That's open to all sorts of angle-shooting in a self-dealt game.

What was suggested seems appropriate to me.


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: david3103 on October 19, 2011, 12:01:37 PM
That's open to all sorts of angle-shooting in a self-dealt game.

My thoughts exactly - indeed I threatened to raise every hand tha was folded to me and then deal the flop instantly

What was suggested seems appropriate to me.

and to me - but, and I've done further searching since my original post

4.    Prior to completion of the betting a card exposed in error by the dealer will be shuffled back into the remaining live deck.
If 2 or 3 cards of the flop have been dealt then the flop will stand. Any player who has missed their turn to act will have automatically checked or any player who has not called a bet/raise will have a dead hand.

http://www.grosvenorukpokertour.com/Qualification/GUKPT-Rules/



Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: AdamM on October 19, 2011, 12:14:36 PM
This is why the dealer bangs the table before dealing community cards.
To allow players who've been missed to pipe up.


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: Karabiner on October 19, 2011, 12:18:07 PM
Self-dealt games make it very difficult for the card-room supervisor to make rulings due to the wide variety of dealing skills.


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: tonytats on October 19, 2011, 01:24:23 PM
This is why the dealer bangs the table before dealing community cards.
To allow players who've been missed to pipe up.

I never knew why they did that do now tho


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: david3103 on October 19, 2011, 01:44:31 PM
This is why the dealer bangs the table before dealing community cards.
To allow players who've been missed to pipe up.

I never knew why they did that do now tho

+1

will have to retrain myself


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: doubleup on October 19, 2011, 01:44:54 PM

4.    Prior to completion of the betting a card exposed in error by the dealer will be shuffled back into the remaining live deck.
If 2 or 3 cards of the flop have been dealt then the flop will stand. Any player who has missed their turn to act will have automatically checked or any player who has not called a bet/raise will have a dead hand.

http://www.grosvenorukpokertour.com/Qualification/GUKPT-Rules/



That is just nonsense.  Whoever wrote that rule is an idiot.  


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: doogan on October 19, 2011, 01:47:53 PM
lol phatomch did, with raaby,zac and jeff leigh


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: doubleup on October 19, 2011, 01:51:44 PM
lol phatomch did, with raaby,zac and jeff leigh

ok sry whoever wrote that rule is idiots


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: cambridgealex on October 19, 2011, 02:09:42 PM
The vic have that rule, I think it's awful too but hey, if thats the rule...


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: Karabiner on October 19, 2011, 03:18:53 PM
I think they also have that rule where if three people check behind you before you have acted your hand is dead.


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: zerofive on October 19, 2011, 03:39:38 PM
I think they also have that rule where if three people check behind you before you have acted your hand is dead.

This is what's called "significant action," I used to see it all the time as a dealer, but would just ignore the players checking out of turn unless the situation was about to get dire, then I would call everyone an idiot and still not kill the hand. It's such an easy method of angle-shooting and colluding.

As for dealing the flop before action has finished, the first thing to do is facepalm, then apologise profusely. If you're dealing in the G then I guess you have to follow their ridiculous set of "rules." Scoop up all the community cards dealt thus far, and reshuffle. Dealing natural turn and natural river is terrible, despite that being the rule at Dusk. With turn and river dealt already, you know three cards that the turn or river cannot be, thus giving 6.5% edge to players drawing to those cards.

Banging the table is a good way of getting everyone's attention, and dealing a spread flop so that any player with something to say has the time it takes you to put three cards face down on the felt to do so. If they haven't piped up by then, then you can start to shift the blame anyway. ;)


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: Ironside on October 19, 2011, 03:50:55 PM
last night in a pub game i was running the big blind announced raise and before he put chips in pot dealer started dealing flop, the ruling i gave was the burn card stood but other cards were shuffled back into deck and the blind was allowed to raise and others could respond seems the only fair ruling imho


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: david3103 on October 20, 2011, 10:33:43 PM
last night in a pub game i was running the big blind announced raise and before he put chips in pot dealer started dealing flop, the ruling i gave was the burn card stood but other cards were shuffled back into deck and the blind was allowed to raise and others could respond seems the only fair ruling imho

Why would burn card stand?


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: Ironside on October 21, 2011, 08:43:24 PM
cauae it would of been the burn card and as it doesnt effect the betting


Title: Re: Ruling query
Post by: smashedagain on October 21, 2011, 11:21:17 PM
I think they also have that rule where if three people check behind you before you have acted your hand is dead.

This is what's called "significant action," I used to see it all the time as a dealer, but would just ignore the players checking out of turn unless the situation was about to get dire, then I would call everyone an idiot and still not kill the hand. It's such an easy method of angle-shooting and colluding.

As for dealing the flop before action has finished, the first thing to do is facepalm, then apologise profusely. If you're dealing in the G then I guess you have to follow their ridiculous set of "rules." Scoop up all the community cards dealt thus far, and reshuffle. Dealing natural turn and natural river is terrible, despite that being the rule at Dusk. With turn and river dealt already, you know three cards that the turn or river cannot be, thus giving 6.5% edge to players drawing to those cards.

Banging the table is a good way of getting everyone's attention, and dealing a spread flop so that any player with something to say has the time it takes you to put three cards face down on the felt to do so. If they haven't piped up by then, then you can start to shift the blame anyway. ;)