Tong g moment, help please

Tiger-flash

Jr. Member

Offline

Posts: 86

Apat East Midlands capt

Tong g moment, help please

« on: October 14, 2011, 08:55:30 PM »

need help here guys if this moment happens again
17 player tourney at the pub last night, the 1st game of a new league
jane, who has been chip leader all night was heads up with my friend aaron, i were dealing for the final table
aaron claws it back to take the lead about 3-1 up in chips then this happens......
aaron limps in on small blind and jane in the bb checks
the flop 663, aaron goes all in and jane calls immeadiately, the rest watching go crazy (to probably see the game finish) and aaron shows 68
to everyones amazement i stop the game, as jane was the bb and should of had the option to check first but aaron went all in out of turn it made her mind up straight away.
I tried to explain to him that you cant do this but he said to me that it didnt matter as she called the all in already
I dissagreed with him and explained that tony g did this on the tv and got penallised and couldnt put any more chips into the pot and it had to be checked down as he bet out of turn
jane told me she would of checked the flop first and if aaron did go all in she would of probably called but wasnt 100%
Half the pub agreed with me and the others werent sure or agreed with aaron
aaron argued with me for around 5 mins over the ruling so we both agreed to take the all in away and just play for the chips before the turn
anyway the turn was an 8 and the river was a jack giving aaron a full house and jane showed 2 pair with aj
aaron said he would of won the match by now but only won the small pot, he went on tilt and jane eventually won the match
This left a bad taste in the pub and spoilt a good nights poker game
who was right, me or him?


	Logged

SuuPRlim

Hero Member

Offline

Posts: 10437

Re: Tong g moment, help please

« Reply #1 on: October 14, 2011, 09:00:20 PM »

the ruling is....

Aaron's all in stands, but action is refered back to Jane who has the same two options, bet or check.

If She checks, Aaron is committed to the all in, if she bets, aaron can take his all in back and has the complete option once again.

So the ruling you gave is actually wrong, sorry to say, and once Jane has said call, that stands and she is now committed to call the out of turn bet.