"Villain is a good player, capable of creative plays"
.....mmmm, calling from the BB with
is certainly creative.
Normally I would say that as described he is a fishy luckbox. But if a player has a reliable read that you have a big pair then (if he is deepstacked and so are you) he can pretty much call with any two cards. There are plenty of cash players who take this line.
I just wonder if he had some kind of tell on you? Did he know this was your last hand? Were you so tight that you could only be raising UTG with such a hand?
..and as someone said, this is live poker, so nothing should surprise you. Also, just because he has a big stack doesn't mean a thing. It's how he accumulated it that is relevant.
- On a general level, everyone expects everyone to play their last hand once they announce it. Unless this guy has a seeing eye, it is more likely that he believes hero is light than it is that he believes he has a big pair;
- Hero has noted Villain was unhappy at losing previous pots, making it more likely that he says "fuck it, I'll play any two out of spite seeing as it is his last hand;
- Live 1 / 2 players are fucking idiots until proven otherwise, guilty until proven innocent so to speak;
- 100BBs is NOT especially deep, and is not deep enough to make defending Q5o correct;
- If he called because he had some 'read' that hero has JJ+ and was trying to outflop - i.e. if he had as logical a thought process as you contend - then he should fall the flop, rather than calling for the five outer. Right?;
People play bad and get lucky all the time at these stakes. Though, hero should:
A) Be thinking about ways to get all the loot in 100BBs deep with an big overpair to the board rather than finding ways to justify a fold;
B) Plan ahead in a hand;