WTF is this? Hull moaning about Bennett making the CORRECT decision?

[The Camel]

http://msn.football365.com/story/0,17033,8652_4728498,00.html

Bennett incorrectly gives a pen. Gets advice there wasn't a handball, and overturns his decision. Does it matter how he comes to the correct decision?

[Colchester Kev]

Of course it matters, If the lino received information from a 3rd party via his earpiece from someone who had seen a replay, then its wrong.

Obv the truth will never come out, so we will never know.


The standard of refereeing is woeful in the premier league though, something needs to be done and quick.

[bolt pp]

It's fin, they get enough of these decisssions go against them, only fair that when they get on in their favour it gets through.

[Rod Paradise]

Of course it matters, If the lino received information from a 3rd party via his earpiece from someone who had seen a replay, then its wrong.

Obv the truth will never come out, so we will never know.


The standard of refereeing is woeful in the premier league though, something needs to be done and quick.

Linesman never signalled a penalty though did he? So by not signalling he was showing he disagreed.

[Colchester Kev]

It's fin, they get enough of these decisssions go against them, only fair that when they get on in their favour it gets through.

I never thought I would ever have to say this to you bolt ... BUT .... You havent had enough E's

[The Camel]

Of course it matters, If the lino received information from a 3rd party via his earpiece from someone who had seen a replay, then its wrong.

Obv the truth will never come out, so we will never know.


The standard of refereeing is woeful in the premier league though, something needs to be done and quick.

World Cup final. I am 99% sure that neither the ref or the linesmen saw Zidane nut Matterazzi. Yet he was sent off. It was the correct decision.

Even if a third party told Bennett and the lino that there was no handball, that must be better than giving the wrong decision.

[Colchester Kev]

Of course it matters, If the lino received information from a 3rd party via his earpiece from someone who had seen a replay, then its wrong.

Obv the truth will never come out, so we will never know.


The standard of refereeing is woeful in the premier league though, something needs to be done and quick.

World Cup final. I am 99% sure that neither the ref or the linesmen saw Zidane nut Matterazzi. Yet he was sent off. It was the correct decision.

Even if a third party told Bennett and the lino that there was no handball, that must be better than giving the wrong decision.

Yes its better, BUT only if that is the accepted rules of the game, At the moment it isnt and therefore should not be allowed.

I think 99% of footy fans want the game to accept the use of technology in some shape or form, but until that time comes, we have to rely on the Ref and his assistants.

[bolt pp]

It's fin, they get enough of these decisssions go against them, only fair that when they get on in their favour it gets through.

I never thought I would ever have to say this to you bolt ... BUT .... You havent had enough E's

why?


these rics are part of the game now, a huge part really, the scream ups the managers have about bad decissions against them has become a part of the game, sky and MOTD would go loopy if managers stopped and if you look at it from the managers point of view this is big bussiness, it's survival and having a moan about it has become an intrisic part of the game.

I'll admit it's a creative moan, but why not? how often do you see a dodgy pen go through without the ref consulting his linesman, it's only fair that when you finally get one in your favour and the ref gives it then goes off to and is influenced by someone else into overturning that decission you have a bit of a scream up about it, it's about consistency really no?

[bolt pp]

It's fin, they get enough of these decisssions go against them, only fair that when they get on in their favour it gets through.

I never thought I would ever have to say this to you bolt ... BUT .... You havent had enough E's

bold statement to make on new years day!

[Colchester Kev]

It's fin, they get enough of these decisssions go against them, only fair that when they get on in their favour it gets through.

I never thought I would ever have to say this to you bolt ... BUT .... You havent had enough E's

bold statement to make on new years day!

Re read your post you mug ... Not enough E's !

[bolt pp]

It's fin, they get enough of these decisssions go against them, only fair that when they get on in their favour it gets through.

I never thought I would ever have to say this to you bolt ... BUT .... You havent had enough E's

bold statement to make on new years day!

Re read your post you mug ... Not enough E's !

sigh, lol, couldnt you have said that before i went on to write THREE paragraphs FFS ive only just got up!!!!!

been awake 1/2 hour and all i'm worrying about is E's and lines!!

[mondatoo]

It's fin, they get enough of these decisssions go against them, only fair that when they get on in their favour it gets through.

I never thought I would ever have to say this to you bolt ... BUT .... You havent had enough E's

bold statement to make on new years day!

Re read your post you mug ... Not enough E's !

lol, couldnt you have said that before i went on to write THREE paragraphs FFS ive only just got up!!!!!

been awake 1/2 hour and all i'm worrying about is E's and lines!!!

Is kev guna give you lines for your mistake,if thats new rules on blonde i'm fooked

[kinboshi]

Of course it matters, If the lino received information from a 3rd party via his earpiece from someone who had seen a replay, then its wrong.

Obv the truth will never come out, so we will never know.


The standard of refereeing is woeful in the premier league though, something needs to be done and quick.

World Cup final. I am 99% sure that neither the ref or the linesmen saw Zidane nut Matterazzi. Yet he was sent off. It was the correct decision.

Even if a third party told Bennett and the lino that there was no handball, that must be better than giving the wrong decision.

I thought it was Gareth Barry who told the ref that he'd made the wrong decision?

[Geo the Sarge]

Of course it matters, If the lino received information from a 3rd party via his earpiece from someone who had seen a replay, then its wrong.

Obv the truth will never come out, so we will never know.


The standard of refereeing is woeful in the premier league though, something needs to be done and quick.

Doubt it's been 3rd party info to linesman as all 4 officials are miked up so any 3rd party info would go straight to the ref who wouldn't need to consult the lino.

From what I seen, lino clearly thought it was no penalty and rightly assisted the ref in making the correct decision.

Geo

[steeveg]

it was the right decision not to give a pen, but the linesman looked as though he was getting advice ,maybe from someone using replay which is against the rules,a similar situation popped up in a American football game a few weeks back. ref was accused of looking up at the replay on video screens around the ground,again right decision but against the rules