Citeh vs LFC a question for the 'neutrals'

[Solaris]

Like the way Wilshere is conviently forgotten even tho he is obviously the best midfielder in the prem and cost 0

Really ? He has massive potential and is already v good but no way is he the best midfielder in the Lge, I would take : Bale/Modric/Nasri/Silva/Toure ahead of him for starters.

You realise Bale is a winger and not a central midfielder like Wilshere, right?

If you'd watched Nasri at all you know he's been average at best at City this season and had half a good season at Arsenal last year before disappearing off the face of the Earth. I'd take Wilshere over him every single day of the week.

I do realise where Bale plays yes, I also realise that Dubai said midfielder not central midfielder.

Arguing semantics because your wrong. Brilliant.

Nice to see you didn't put up an argument for your inclusion of Nasri. Then again it's pointless arguing with people who actually watch him play so I don't blame you.

You really can't have a debate can you? Anyone with a different opinion is just wrong.
Monda owned you here and you react like a little brat.

Is a winger a midfielder to you? To me he's a winger. There's a difference that is so unbelievably obvious I really fail to see how you can't see it. Comparing Bale to Wilshere is a complete and utter waste of time.

On top of that, including Nasri is a sure sign of someone who doesn't actually watch football all that much as they'd be aware that he's been average at City and really wasn't as great as he was made out to be at Arsenal.

Feel free to tell me what part of what I've said is wrong.

Your fascination with trying to insult me is flattering, I must say. You're going to have to do a lot better as your insults are pretty poor. Good luck.

[mulhuzz]

i'll bite.

i'd play bale in wilshire's position before wilshire.

[Solaris]

i'll bite.

i'd play bale in wilshire's position before wilshire.

Are you and Pleno a comedy duo?

[mondatoo]

I thought a winger was someone who played Left Midfield or Right Midfield ?

As for form, that's what it is, form. He's a class player and has done more than Wilshire due to the fact Wilshire is 20 years old and has played 38 games thus is still unproven so I'd rather have Nasri. It's also not that unusual for someone to start slowly at a new club so I'm sure Mancini's not to worried about Nasri.

You come across very aggressive and patronising but I'm sure this is just the way you are and not just another one of the internet's special people.

[Solaris]

I thought a winger was someone who played Left Midfield or Right Midfield ?

As for form, that's what it is, form. He's a class player and has done more than Wilshire due to the fact Wilshire is 20 years old and has played 38 games thus is still unproven so I'd rather have Nasri. It's also not that unusual for someone to start slowly at a new club so I'm sure Mancini's not to worried about Nasri.

You come across very aggressive and patronising but I'm sure this is just the way you are and not just another one of the internet's special people.

Wilshere was infinitely better than Nasri at Arsenal. The fact you don't know this is because you didn't watch him. Why you're trying to arguing with someone who watched them play every single minute of every game is beyond me.

It's like me trying to tell you who Newcastle's best players are. I couldn't because I know I don't watch the whole 90 minutes of every one of their games.

As I've said multiple times, Nasri had 6 good months at Arsenal in his entire career there. Wilshere had an excellent season for the entirety of it.

[Josedinho]

Like the way Wilshere is conviently forgotten even tho he is obviously the best midfielder in the prem and cost 0

Really ? He has massive potential and is already v good but no way is he the best midfielder in the Lge, I would take : Bale/Modric/Nasri/Silva/Toure ahead of him for starters.

You realise Bale is a winger and not a central midfielder like Wilshere, right?

If you'd watched Nasri at all you know he's been average at best at City this season and had half a good season at Arsenal last year before disappearing off the face of the Earth. I'd take Wilshere over him every single day of the week.

I do realise where Bale plays yes, I also realise that Dubai said midfielder not central midfielder.

Arguing semantics because your wrong. Brilliant.

Nice to see you didn't put up an argument for your inclusion of Nasri. Then again it's pointless arguing with people who actually watch him play so I don't blame you.

You really can't have a debate can you? Anyone with a different opinion is just wrong.
Monda owned you here and you react like a little brat.

Is a winger a midfielder to you? To me he's a winger. There's a difference that is so unbelievably obvious I really fail to see how you can't see it. Comparing Bale to Wilshere is a complete and utter waste of time.

Irrelevant point

Sarcy Comment

Blah

http://www.faw.org.uk/PlayerDisplay.ink?skip=0&squadno=11129&season=11/12&seasonl=2011/2012&Playertype=p
http://www.tottenhamhotspur.com/players/first_team/garethbale.html
Wales and Spurs both list Bale as a midfielder. I think it's quite reasonable for Monda to include him in a debate on midfielders if he thinks his talent is deserving of being included.
Instead of saying something like "I disagree but it's hard to compare as they play different roles, I believe Dubai was probably referring to central midfielders" you try and make somebody look a dick.

[mulhuzz]

i'll bite.

i'd play bale in wilshire's position before wilshire.

Are you and Pleno a comedy duo?

i would do anything to see both harry 'other people's players' redknapp and arsene 'i did not see the incident' wenger lose games, if that means playing two players oop, fine with me.

[mondatoo]

I'm not trying to argue with you, I gave my opinion, just because you disagree with it and have watched them play more doesn't mean mine has to change. I am really suprised that Wenger and the Arsenal fans didn't want to snap City's hands off when they offered so much for Nasri if he was only good for 6 months, as I remember it nobody wanted him to leave ?

[Solaris]

http://www.faw.org.uk/PlayerDisplay.ink?skip=0&squadno=11129&season=11/12&seasonl=2011/2012&Playertype=p
http://www.tottenhamhotspur.com/players/first_team/garethbale.html
Wales and Spurs both list Bale as a midfielder. I think it's quite reasonable for Monda to include him in a debate on midfielders if he thinks his talent is deserving of being included.
Instead of saying something like "I disagree but it's hard to compare as they play different roles, I believe Dubai was probably referring to central midfielders" you try and make somebody look a dick.

I really didn't think it needed explaining. I would have thought it would be fairly obvious that comparing Bale and Wilshere was a complete waste of time. My mistake for assuming you're clever enough to make this fairly obvious distinction.

[chatban]

Numerous assaults Solaris.

Seems a bit of a villain.

[Solaris]

I'm not trying to argue with you, I gave my opinion, just because you disagree with it and have watched them play more doesn't mean mine has to change. I am really suprised that Wenger and the Arsenal fans didn't want to snap City's hands off when they offered so much for Nasri if he was only good for 6 months, as I remember it nobody wanted him to leave ?

We didn't want a good player to join our rival's, but most of all we were all pissed off with the way in which it happened. His head was completely turned by City because of the stupid money on offer to him. He's a greedy SOB whose greed is getting in the way of his ability. There was also the fact that Arsene left it so close to the season beginning that made the situation difficult. Having lost Cesc and with no obvious replacement lined up this was the only reason some people were hoping he might stay. Had he shipped him off in the summer and brought in players before the season began things would definitely have been a lot easier for us and no-one would have cared.

Nearly any Arsenal fan you will speak too can't believe we got 25 mill for a player in his last year. It was excellent business.

[George2Loose]

Whole who is better than who argument is pretty pointless if you ask me

Although no one did so carry on.

However I would say that saying Wilshere is the best midfielder in the prem based on one season is OTT.

[mondatoo]

Pretty suprised to read that Nasri has the 2nd highest amount of assist in the League after Silva who the pundits say is currently the best player in the league, if that's Nasri when he's shit how good will he be when he sorts his form out.

[Solaris]

Pretty suprised to read that Nasri has the 2nd highest amount of assist in the League after Silva who the pundits say is currently the best player in the league, if that's Nasri when he's shit how good will he be when he sorts his form out.

[ ] statistics always prove a point

[mondatoo]

Just saying, obv statistics can be misleading but I genuinely was suprised when I read it on the updates for the City game, lots of people seem to be critical of him this season so obv he hasn't been amazing. Pretty sure you are biased though with your Arsenal connections but you aren't the first or the last to be biased about a football discussion.