Nah I disagree on this one Cos.
If it was just weights then the protein shake would suffice, but it's not.
I take the carbs at the gym, straight after finishing my run. When your at the gym for that long you need the carbs. Takes me 10-15 mins to get home. Once back I have a protein shake. Its a system that works for me.
I'm no expert on running but this seems a bit back to front to me.
Surely if you're going to have a carb drink you take it before your run to provide the energy to train? If you take your carbs after running what are they going to be used for? Your body doesn't hang around waiting for energy to do something. It'll have found it from somewhere to get you through your run and it shouldn't need topping up unless you're severely dehydrated.
If you take a carb drink you're just pumping yourself full of sugar which isn't going to get used so will be stored.
On top of this you're taking on a protein shake which just adds more calories to your count.
I can't understand the 'meh at the cals' statement?
You've got no chance of losing 2st in 3 months if that's your attitude.
Calories are the key to this and every unnecessary one you consume makes your goal that little bit more difficult to attain.
If you struggle to walk the next day you'd be better off shortening your run to a point where you can walk and removing the carb drink.