Doctor Who - WP Matt Smith

[Cf]

Doctor Who was awesome.

The programme on before was not. I have sent a complaint to the BBC about it.

[TRIP5]

Well, I for one hated the first episode of series 2...I thought it was fragmanted, poorly indroduced and overall not one of the best!!!! I was disappointed with last seasons arc, i thought there were too many filler episodes and not enough substance!

I'm a bit gutted as I'm a HUGE Doctor Who fan but all this guff about; is the girl in the spacesuit River Song, is Amy's baby River Song, the death of the Doctor in the first 5 mins AND that DREADFUL TBC all spoiled it for me...I'll watch next weeks as it's a two parter but I doubt this will be a 'must see' for me after that!!

xx

[Cf]

Well, I for one hated the first episode of series 2...I thought it was fragmanted, poorly indroduced and overall not one of the best!!!! I was disappointed with last seasons arc, i thought there were too many filler episodes and not enough substance!

I'm a bit gutted as I'm a HUGE Doctor Who fan but all this guff about; is the girl in the spacesuit River Song, is Amy's baby River Song, the death of the Doctor in the first 5 mins AND that DREADFUL TBC all spoiled it for me...I'll watch next weeks as it's a two parter but I doubt this will be a 'must see' for me after that!!

xx

dislike

Although I will admit that for a series opener it was perhaps a tad slow. A consequence of being a two parter no doubt. And not only was it setting its own story up it was setting the series' story.

[TommyD]

Well, I for one hated the first episode of series 2...I thought it was fragmanted, poorly indroduced and overall not one of the best!!!! I was disappointed with last seasons arc, i thought there were too many filler episodes and not enough substance!

I'm a bit gutted as I'm a HUGE Doctor Who fan but all this guff about; is the girl in the spacesuit River Song, is Amy's baby River Song, the death of the Doctor in the first 5 mins AND that DREADFUL TBC all spoiled it for me...I'll watch next weeks as it's a two parter but I doubt this will be a 'must see' for me after that!!

xx

Wow, I loved it.  Thought it was the really strong and can't wait for the conclusion.  To attempt to answer your questions in order:  Very likely, probably and the death of the Doctor is setting up the story arc for the series, a concept and plot I adore.

[TRIP5]

Well, sometimes it's best to be in the minority imo!!!! I really hope to be proved wrong, then again I waited thoughout the whole of last season to be 'wowed' but it never really happened...even after rewatching it wasn't much better... And please don't get me started on the farce of a Christmas episode, it was almost as bad as the one with Kyle ffs!!!!!!

This series was promised to be 'darker' ...I can only hope part 2 picks up for me!!! One thought...Doctor is 1103 with no tardis because he's been stuck in the past, waiting to catch up with Amy, River & Rory...

For me, it's still not as good as Tennant & Russell...maybe that's the problem...

xx

[Supernova]

Well, I for one hated the first episode of series 2...I thought it was fragmanted, poorly indroduced and overall not one of the best!!!! I was disappointed with last seasons arc, i thought there were too many filler episodes and not enough substance!

I'm a bit gutted as I'm a HUGE Doctor Who fan but all this guff about; is the girl in the spacesuit River Song, is Amy's baby River Song, the death of the Doctor in the first 5 mins AND that DREADFUL TBC all spoiled it for me...I'll watch next weeks as it's a two parter but I doubt this will be a 'must see' for me after that!!

xx

Wow, I loved it.  Thought it was the really strong and can't wait for the conclusion.  To attempt to answer your questions in order:  Very likely, probably and the death of the Doctor is setting up the story arc for the series, a concept and plot I adore.

I thought it was awesome and the trailers for episode 2 from the BBC homepage look pretty scary.....says she who has to check the Angel in the churchyard at Shepperton is still there when she drives past lol.

Persevere Irene, Dr Who confidential had a few clues and there are alot of threads going on that will become apparently become clearer and much darker later.

Smith is looking like he's going to be the best doctor so far for me and Steven Moffat is an amazing writer, he can make so many ordinary things become a nightmare, remember Blink & The Silence in the Library....

[George2Loose]

I honestly thought no would top Tennant but must admit Matt Smith may just be sneaking ahead in my estimation

[Cf]

I really liked Tennant back in the day but can't help but think of his last few episodes and it just drops my opionion of his doctor. I know it's not his fault that he was given those scripts to work with but I struggle to look past "I don't want to go" and the 15 minutes of embarrasment that came with it.

[AndrewT]

I honestly thought no would top Tennant but must admit Matt Smith may just be sneaking ahead in my estimation

Matt Smith was ahead of Tennant within 10 mins of his first episode.

And I really liked Tennant.

[the sicilian]

I was very dubious about Matt Smith... The kids and I have loved the new Doctor Who from day 1 and didn't think anyone could top Tennant as we all thought he was the epitome of the doctor .. but Matt has brought together what the doctor is all about... zany eccentric genius + more and made it his own inside one sereis.... gotta love the jammy dodgers and a fez line... thought the first episode was great..non linear..mysterious, funny, creepy, dark all in one show.... luv it !!

oh and I love the series thread story they do...

[TRIP5]

Doctor Who Ep 2

Let part two commence

xx

[TRIP5]

Doctor Who Ep 2

Let part two commence

xx

Ooooo

Won't post any spoilers for those at GUKPT...just Oooooo

xx

[Cf]

If it's aired then talking about it in here is fair game. Just avoid thread until you watch.

Great ep. I'm assuming the child is River, with Amy being River's mother. Or something.

[George2Loose]

If it's aired then talking about it in here is fair game. Just avoid thread until you watch.

Great ep. I'm assuming the child is River, with Amy being River's mother. Or something.

Yeh that's the gossip. Didn't enjoy it too much for some reaosn

[TRIP5]

If it's aired then talking about it in here is fair game. Just avoid thread until you watch.

Great ep. I'm assuming the child is River, with Amy being River's mother. Or something.

Yeh that's the gossip. Didn't enjoy it too much for some reaosn

I could elaborate...but I wont

Imna gonna wait til Superduper catches up innit

xx