Players you rate when no one else does, or rated players you think are pants.

[ForthThistle]

over rated

kuyt
capello
berbatov
freddy adu
green
foster
kirkland
Gabriel Agbonlahor
most english palyers





underrated

gary nevlle
steve irwin
akinfeev
fletcher

PMSL... Was Steve Irwin not stingrayed

[geordieneil]

most under rated player of all time has to be peter beardsley

most over rated obefemi martins, shay given, david ginola

[sweet potata!]

What i like about Paul Scharner is that he can make a good fist of playing at the back or as an attacking midfielder and hes very good in the air, not that common among players. Obv I aint saying he's brilliant just under rated thats all.

[redarmi]

Brad Jones

Us Boro fans are still in shock that we could get £2.3m for him.

Overrated

Terry (once had ability control pace of games...now is just slow and believes his own hype)
Gerrard (is clearly a superb player but just not as good as scousers will have you believe)

Underrated

Roger Johnson
Stephen Ireland
Clint Dempsey


Have a feeling Torres will be overrated this year.

[sweet potata!]

Brad Jones

Us Boro fans are still in shock that we could get £2.3m for him.

Overrated

Terry (once had ability control pace of games...now is just slow and believes his own hype)
Gerrard (is clearly a superb player but just not as good as scousers will have you believe)

Underrated

Roger Johnson
Stephen Ireland
Clint Dempsey


Have a feeling Torres will be overrated this year.

Its a bit worrying as a Liverpool supporter that since we have signed Brad Jones it appears everyone thinks he is tez, I dont know anything about him myself but it dosent look too good!

Clint Dempsey is a decent shout he usually puts in a good shift when i see him.

[The Camel]

Brad Jones

Us Boro fans are still in shock that we could get £2.3m for him.

Overrated

Terry (once had ability control pace of games...now is just slow and believes his own hype)
Gerrard (is clearly a superb player but just not as good as scousers will have you believe)

Underrated

Roger Johnson
Stephen Ireland
Clint Dempsey


Have a feeling Torres will be overrated this year.

Another good call.

Very good player, maybe. But world class? LOL. Wouldn't even get in the Spain, Brazil or Argentine squads, let alone the first teams.

I like Scharner as a midfielder, so competitive and a great man to man marker. Obviously not going to create much, but you wouldn't put in the team for that.

[Horneris]

Us Boro fans are still in shock that we could get £2.3m for him.

omg. Boro in "fan" shock.

[the sicilian]

overrated:

Bent......urrrrgh !
Andriy Shevchenko

By the way am i the only person who thinks the liverpool goalkeeper deliberately pushed the ball into his own net Sunday...looked pretty suspicious to me..bungs and fixing ftw

[Hairydude]

overrated:

Bent......urrrrgh !
Andriy Shevchenko

By the way am i the only person who thinks the liverpool goalkeeper deliberately pushed the ball into his own net Sunday...looked pretty suspicious to me..bungs and fixing ftw

How dare you....a red would never do such a thing

[paulhouk03]

Shevchenko was amazing untill He joined chelsea

[gatso]

overrated:

Bent......urrrrgh !
Andriy Shevchenko

lol @ bent being overrated. shevchenko though absolutely. he's still idolised by dynamo kiev fans who think he's the bollocks but he was terrible last season (though I did see him stay on the pitch despite getting booked twice against shakhtar, was pretty com as the whole ground went mental but the ref was oblivious to it)

By the way am i the only person who thinks the liverpool goalkeeper deliberately pushed the ball into his own net Sunday...looked pretty suspicious to me..bungs and fixing ftw

meh, I mentioned this on another thread and got accused of watching the game in an assylum or something like that

[geordieneil]

Us Boro fans are still in shock that we could get £2.3m for him.

omg.  a Boro  "fan"

FYP

[The Baron]

Brad Jones

Us Boro fans are still in shock that we could get £2.3m for him.

Overrated

Terry (once had ability control pace of games...now is just slow and believes his own hype)
Gerrard (is clearly a superb player but just not as good as scousers will have you believe)

Underrated

Roger Johnson
Stephen Ireland
Clint Dempsey


Have a feeling Torres will be overrated this year.

Another good call.

Very good player, maybe. But world class? LOL. Wouldn't even get in the Spain, Brazil or Argentine squads, let alone the first teams.

I like Scharner as a midfielder, so competitive and a great man to man marker. Obviously not going to create much, but you wouldn't put in the team for that.

Based on last season he wouldn't get into many sides but Brazil and Argentina?

Over all time great CMs such as Veron, Melo, Gilberto Silva, Cambiasso, Rameires, Kleberson, Lucas, Maxi and other such world beaters? lol

He could crawl, without limbs, into either side.

[Acidmouse]

Bent, natural goalscorer done it at some reet shitty clubs.


It a lot better then Keane and Pavo at spurs that's for sure.

[pokerfan]

Heskey , arguments for both.