The fact that you're playing against good players doesn't mean you should live in fear of being blown off every hand
Very true. We're not talking about every hand though we're talking about this one.
You say you expect to get shipped on a very small %age of the time.
How often do you expect to get called by a 'very very good' player?
Do you think he calls AK?
With our image he can't ever think AK is good here but he may have done when he initially bet.
If he was value betting he was probably going for the old bet/fold move himself so doesn't pay you off. Alternatively he may decide you haven't got much better than him, turn his hand in to a bluff and jam. (Unlikely but possible)
If he was bluffing he's never paying you off but may jam thinking you are bluffing (again unlikely but possible)
If he has a set he probably jams or at least calls.
Basically from what I can see he's not calling with anything you beat.
The most likely things for him to do are fold, then jam, then call in that order.
If I'm raise/folding I want that order to be call, then fold, then jam.
Don't get me wrong I'm giving the guy a lot of credit here which he perhaps doesn't deserve.
If calling with worse seems to outweigh his other options then ofc raise/fold is great. I don't see it here though.