Yes Rob of course as i said earlier "the game is the same for all of us" my point is that your suggestion that "14.5 BB's average give lot's of play" is simply silly.
I am not one of those who goes to these comps and compains about the structure, i do not play live weekly comps because almost every one has a horrible, horrilbe structure. I would rather play a £50 freezeout online where i actually get some play, without being shouted at or having someone try to give me lung cancer!
i agree with you that players who moan about the levels who play week in week out our silly, if they do not like it, then there are other options.
Now i know all these things have to be done by 4/5am so you do give as much play as possible, however please do not tell the players that 14.5BB's allows plenty of play, it removes all confidence that you understand the players perspective.
as I said before an average stack of 14.5 big blinds allows considerably more play options than an average stack of 5 big blinds
(If you look very carefully you may be able to detect a slight edge of sarcasm in my typing during the example)
Anyway I think you are fixating on this a little too much!
If you go back and read the earlier thread my initial example had the BB ratio at over 20. This being deemed comfortable earlier in the final. in this example the BB ratio of Average stack never falls below 17.
Average stack means some ARE lower and some are higher.
About understanding Player's perspective:
Are telling me that all players value exactly the same thing
play the same way
want the same structure.
If so then this is very naive
Different players want different things
No player is the same
You prefer a slow game some prefer a fast game
There is no easy to define collective 'player perspective'
Your opinion is not the representatitive one and give up telling me I don't know what I'm doing> I actually spend an awful lot of time talking to regular players and trying to establish what their perspective is. These people that i serve day in day out have confidence that I understand their perspective.
If all players were the same my job would be easy.