REVERSE SHEEP QUIZ 26 - THE ONE IN ALL CAPS AND WITH ROBERT'S RULES

[Cf]

I'm failing to see how any of the quoted rules cover this.

I've also just found under IRREGULARITIES:

14. If you drop any cards out of your hand onto the floor, you must still play them.

Not quite the same thing, but it possibly suggests that bob doesn't consider this to be a misdeal.

[xxMAIRxx]

but it was not a player who dropped card to the floor, but the dealer. Therefore a misdeal as per rules A and F

[Shogun112]

Please do not try arguing the case any more.  As I said, cant be doing this any more as it is being ruined.  I also see this as the reason 25 players has gone down by half..

[G1BTW]

what if it floats to the ground face down? how's that exposed?

[Cf]

but it was not a player who dropped card to the floor, but the dealer. Therefore a misdeal as per rules A and F

(a) The first or second card of the hand has been exposed by a dealer error.

This rule only applies to the first or second card dealt. So it wouldn't cover it if it was say the 3rd card dealt.

(f) Any card has been dealt out of the proper sequence (except an exposed card may be replaced by the burncard).

And this means dealing to players in the wrong order. I don't think we apply this here.

[xxMAIRxx]

Complete nonsense failing them for this when it is written within the rules as scenarios that could happen and their answer is one of those scenarios.

[gatso]

lol. don't give in to the haters cf

fyi most london cardrooms and several in europe do not declare a misdeal for a floored card, it is put faceup on the table and treated as an exposed card

[The_duke]

(a) The first or second card of the hand has been exposed by a dealer error.

This rule only applies to the first or second card dealt. So it wouldn't cover it if it was say the 3rd card dealt.

for the purpose of this quiz it could have been the first card so not a fail

[Cf]

lol. don't give in to the haters cf

fyi most london cardrooms and several in europe do not declare a misdeal for a floored card, it is put faceup on the table and treated as an exposed card

This makes sense.

I only consider this to be a misdeal because everywhere I play treats it as one.

Treating it as an exposed cards makes more sense to me.

[Shogun112]

move on...

[xxMAIRxx]

Well gr8 start to your job as QM cf, another 2 people lost from the RSQ and I expect more to follow and here I thought you would be a fair QM

[Cf]

Ok, moving on. I'm just glad RichEO wasn't here. I've even got a thread discussing his scenario on another forum lol.

SCORES AFTER QUESTION 1

Girgy85: 0
cdw1111: 0
xxMAIRxx: 0
Stokes: 1
kinboshi: 2
G1BTW: 2
The_duke: 2
Laxie: 2
Josedinho: 5
RichEO: 5
Shogun112: 5
TightEnd: 5

[Cf]

Should be slightly more plain sailing for a while now

[Shogun112]

Well gr8 start to your job as QM cf, another 2 people lost from the RSQ and I expect more to follow and here I thought you would be a fair QM

[Cf]

QUESTION 2 - Download Festival 2009 was recently held at Donington Park. Name a band who has headlined the main stage of the festival from 2003 and onwards.

SHEEP - Feeder - 3 points
Girgy85
Stokes
TightEnd

ACE - Slipknot - 1 point
Josedinho

ACE - Linkin Park - 1 point
kinboshi

ACE - My Chemical Romance - 1 point
xxMAIRxx

ACE - Black Sabbath - 1 point
The_duke

ACE - ZZ Top - 1 point
Laxie

FAIL - Biffy Clyro - 8 points
RichEO

FAIL - Motorhead - 8 points
Shogun112

FAIL - Kaiser Chiefs - 8 points
cdw1111

FAIL - Ting Tings - 8 points
G1BTW